Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme
Objectives The planning process for a new hospital relies on assumptions about future levels of demand. Typically, such assumptions are characterised by point estimates, the flaw-of-averages, base-rate neglect and overoptimism from an inside view. To counteract these limitations, we elicited an outs...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2024-10-01
|
| Series: | BMJ Open |
| Online Access: | https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/14/10/e084632.full |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1849720497047076864 |
|---|---|
| author | Mohammed A Mohammed Steven Wyatt Thomas Jemmett Josh Cook Jake Parsons Chris Beeley Peter Spilsbury |
| author_facet | Mohammed A Mohammed Steven Wyatt Thomas Jemmett Josh Cook Jake Parsons Chris Beeley Peter Spilsbury |
| author_sort | Mohammed A Mohammed |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Objectives The planning process for a new hospital relies on assumptions about future levels of demand. Typically, such assumptions are characterised by point estimates, the flaw-of-averages, base-rate neglect and overoptimism from an inside view. To counteract these limitations, we elicited an outside view of probabilistic forecasts based on judgements of experts about the extent to which various types of hospital activity might be mitigated over 20 years, in support of the New Hospital Programme (NHP) in the English National Health Service.Design A prospective online elicitation exercise, over two rounds, to forecast the reduction (0% no reduction to 100% total reduction) in 77 types of hospital activity across England via five types of activity mitigation: outpatient attendance avoidance (n=8); inpatient admission avoidance (n=31); A&E attendance avoidance (n=12); outpatient delivery mode (n=4); inpatient length of stay reduction (n=22) and eight types of activity groups.Primary outcomes are the aggregated forecasts representing the percentage reduction (0%–100%) in hospital activity across England based on ‘surprisingly low’ (10th percentile—P10) to ‘surprisingly high’ (90th percentile—P90) forecasts from 17 experts.Results We had 657 forecasts from 17 experts. The most pessimistic forecast was for inpatient avoidance of frail elderly admissions (mean 5.71%, P10=0.43%, P90=16.40%). The most optimistic forecast was for inpatient admission avoidance for vascular surgery (mean 48.27%, P10=19.82%, P90=78.57%). The overall (n=77) aggregate means ranged from a low of 5.71% to a high of 48.27% with an average width of 50.08%. Experts highlighted mainly four types of mitigation mechanisms—prevention, displacement, quality improvement and de-adoption.Conclusion A national elicitation exercise has provided long-term aggregate forecasts across England that make explicit the wide variation and uncertainty associated with future mitigation activities from an outside perspective. These aggregate forecasts may now be incorporated into the NHP, providing a more robust foundation for planning. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-ef8ce95c310a45dc8aec1a6d2f4d2b72 |
| institution | DOAJ |
| issn | 2044-6055 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-10-01 |
| publisher | BMJ Publishing Group |
| record_format | Article |
| series | BMJ Open |
| spelling | doaj-art-ef8ce95c310a45dc8aec1a6d2f4d2b722025-08-20T03:11:54ZengBMJ Publishing GroupBMJ Open2044-60552024-10-01141010.1136/bmjopen-2024-084632Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital ProgrammeMohammed A Mohammed0Steven Wyatt1Thomas Jemmett2Josh Cook3Jake Parsons4Chris Beeley5Peter Spilsbury61 The Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancahsire Commissioning Support Unit, Stoke on Trent, UK1 The Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancahsire Commissioning Support Unit, Stoke on Trent, UKThe Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, Birmingham, UKThe Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, Birmingham, UKThe Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, Birmingham, UKThe Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, Birmingham, UKThe Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, Birmingham, UKObjectives The planning process for a new hospital relies on assumptions about future levels of demand. Typically, such assumptions are characterised by point estimates, the flaw-of-averages, base-rate neglect and overoptimism from an inside view. To counteract these limitations, we elicited an outside view of probabilistic forecasts based on judgements of experts about the extent to which various types of hospital activity might be mitigated over 20 years, in support of the New Hospital Programme (NHP) in the English National Health Service.Design A prospective online elicitation exercise, over two rounds, to forecast the reduction (0% no reduction to 100% total reduction) in 77 types of hospital activity across England via five types of activity mitigation: outpatient attendance avoidance (n=8); inpatient admission avoidance (n=31); A&E attendance avoidance (n=12); outpatient delivery mode (n=4); inpatient length of stay reduction (n=22) and eight types of activity groups.Primary outcomes are the aggregated forecasts representing the percentage reduction (0%–100%) in hospital activity across England based on ‘surprisingly low’ (10th percentile—P10) to ‘surprisingly high’ (90th percentile—P90) forecasts from 17 experts.Results We had 657 forecasts from 17 experts. The most pessimistic forecast was for inpatient avoidance of frail elderly admissions (mean 5.71%, P10=0.43%, P90=16.40%). The most optimistic forecast was for inpatient admission avoidance for vascular surgery (mean 48.27%, P10=19.82%, P90=78.57%). The overall (n=77) aggregate means ranged from a low of 5.71% to a high of 48.27% with an average width of 50.08%. Experts highlighted mainly four types of mitigation mechanisms—prevention, displacement, quality improvement and de-adoption.Conclusion A national elicitation exercise has provided long-term aggregate forecasts across England that make explicit the wide variation and uncertainty associated with future mitigation activities from an outside perspective. These aggregate forecasts may now be incorporated into the NHP, providing a more robust foundation for planning.https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/14/10/e084632.full |
| spellingShingle | Mohammed A Mohammed Steven Wyatt Thomas Jemmett Josh Cook Jake Parsons Chris Beeley Peter Spilsbury Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme BMJ Open |
| title | Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme |
| title_full | Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme |
| title_fullStr | Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme |
| title_full_unstemmed | Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme |
| title_short | Long-term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in English hospitals: a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the New Hospital Programme |
| title_sort | long term probabilistic forecasts of activity mitigation in english hospitals a national elicitation exercise providing an outside view based on judgements of experts in support of the new hospital programme |
| url | https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/14/10/e084632.full |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT mohammedamohammed longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT stevenwyatt longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT thomasjemmett longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT joshcook longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT jakeparsons longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT chrisbeeley longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme AT peterspilsbury longtermprobabilisticforecastsofactivitymitigationinenglishhospitalsanationalelicitationexerciseprovidinganoutsideviewbasedonjudgementsofexpertsinsupportofthenewhospitalprogramme |