Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment
Abstract Purpose Surgical options for end‐stage knee osteoarthritis (OA) include total and medial unicompartmental knee replacement (TKR and UKR). Deciding which surgery to perform is complex and ill‐defined, yet it has important implications for patients and the health service. The study aimed to i...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Wiley
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70178 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850152013452541952 |
|---|---|
| author | Martine Nurek Omar Musbahi Martinique Vella Baldacchino Robert Hamm Caroline B. Hing Justin Cobb Olga Kostopoulou UNITES Consortium |
| author_facet | Martine Nurek Omar Musbahi Martinique Vella Baldacchino Robert Hamm Caroline B. Hing Justin Cobb Olga Kostopoulou UNITES Consortium |
| author_sort | Martine Nurek |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Purpose Surgical options for end‐stage knee osteoarthritis (OA) include total and medial unicompartmental knee replacement (TKR and UKR). Deciding which surgery to perform is complex and ill‐defined, yet it has important implications for patients and the health service. The study aimed to identify clinical and surgeon factors predicting surgeons' preferences. Methods Based on a preliminary survey of 162 UK surgeons, we identified clinical features frequently considered when deciding between TKR and UKR. By systematically varying patient age, obesity, site of pain, anaesthetic risk and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) integrity, we constructed 32 clinical vignettes. We used these in a new survey, where surgeons indicated which surgery they would recommend on an 11‐point rating scale with end points anchored at ‘definitely TKR’ and ‘definitely medial UKR’. Data were analysed with mixed‐effects linear regressions. Results Eighty‐three UK arthroplasty surgeons completed the vignettes. Preference for UKR over TKR was significantly lower for patients over 50 years (b = −0.57 [−0.82 to −0.33], p < 0.001) with abnormal ACL (b = −1.93 [−2.17 to −1.68], p < 0.001) and severe systemic disease (b = −0.46 [−0.70 to −0.21], p < 0.001). Obesity was a weak and unreliable predictor, and we did not detect any influence of site of pain. The surgeons' habitual practice (proportion of UKRs over all knee replacements performed in a typical year) was the second strongest predictor after ACL (b = 1.26 [0.54–1.99], p = 0.001). Conclusions ACL integrity was the most important determinant of surgeons' preferences between TKR and UKR. Their habitual practice was also a strong predictor, outweighing most clinical factors in the vignettes. Level of Evidence Level II, prospective cohort study. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-eda98d5c950b4281844c32458d04cc5b |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 2197-1153 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics |
| spelling | doaj-art-eda98d5c950b4281844c32458d04cc5b2025-08-20T02:26:05ZengWileyJournal of Experimental Orthopaedics2197-11532025-01-01121n/an/a10.1002/jeo2.70178Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experimentMartine Nurek0Omar Musbahi1Martinique Vella Baldacchino2Robert Hamm3Caroline B. Hing4Justin Cobb5Olga Kostopoulou6UNITES ConsortiumDepartment of Surgery and Cancer Imperial College London London UKMSk Lab, Sir Michael Uren Hub Imperial College London London UKMSk Lab, Sir Michael Uren Hub Imperial College London London UKUniversity of Oklahoma Oklahoma USASt George's Hospital NHS Foundation Trust London UKMSk Lab, Sir Michael Uren Hub Imperial College London London UKDepartment of Surgery and Cancer Imperial College London London UKAbstract Purpose Surgical options for end‐stage knee osteoarthritis (OA) include total and medial unicompartmental knee replacement (TKR and UKR). Deciding which surgery to perform is complex and ill‐defined, yet it has important implications for patients and the health service. The study aimed to identify clinical and surgeon factors predicting surgeons' preferences. Methods Based on a preliminary survey of 162 UK surgeons, we identified clinical features frequently considered when deciding between TKR and UKR. By systematically varying patient age, obesity, site of pain, anaesthetic risk and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) integrity, we constructed 32 clinical vignettes. We used these in a new survey, where surgeons indicated which surgery they would recommend on an 11‐point rating scale with end points anchored at ‘definitely TKR’ and ‘definitely medial UKR’. Data were analysed with mixed‐effects linear regressions. Results Eighty‐three UK arthroplasty surgeons completed the vignettes. Preference for UKR over TKR was significantly lower for patients over 50 years (b = −0.57 [−0.82 to −0.33], p < 0.001) with abnormal ACL (b = −1.93 [−2.17 to −1.68], p < 0.001) and severe systemic disease (b = −0.46 [−0.70 to −0.21], p < 0.001). Obesity was a weak and unreliable predictor, and we did not detect any influence of site of pain. The surgeons' habitual practice (proportion of UKRs over all knee replacements performed in a typical year) was the second strongest predictor after ACL (b = 1.26 [0.54–1.99], p = 0.001). Conclusions ACL integrity was the most important determinant of surgeons' preferences between TKR and UKR. Their habitual practice was also a strong predictor, outweighing most clinical factors in the vignettes. Level of Evidence Level II, prospective cohort study.https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70178decision‐makingknee arthroplastyosteoarthritistotal knee arthroplastyunicompartmental |
| spellingShingle | Martine Nurek Omar Musbahi Martinique Vella Baldacchino Robert Hamm Caroline B. Hing Justin Cobb Olga Kostopoulou UNITES Consortium Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics decision‐making knee arthroplasty osteoarthritis total knee arthroplasty unicompartmental |
| title | Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment |
| title_full | Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment |
| title_fullStr | Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment |
| title_full_unstemmed | Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment |
| title_short | Factors influencing UK arthroplasty surgeons' decision‐making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery: A vignette‐based behavioural experiment |
| title_sort | factors influencing uk arthroplasty surgeons decision making between total and medial unicompartmental knee surgery a vignette based behavioural experiment |
| topic | decision‐making knee arthroplasty osteoarthritis total knee arthroplasty unicompartmental |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70178 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT martinenurek factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT omarmusbahi factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT martiniquevellabaldacchino factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT roberthamm factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT carolinebhing factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT justincobb factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT olgakostopoulou factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment AT unitesconsortium factorsinfluencingukarthroplastysurgeonsdecisionmakingbetweentotalandmedialunicompartmentalkneesurgeryavignettebasedbehaviouralexperiment |