Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis

John F. Hartmann (1986) argued that the spread of the Indic languages in Southeast Asia took place in different overlapping periods, through which the region underwent a process of indinization. Hartmann’s thesis is very important to help understand the making of cultural networks in Southeast Asia....

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Agus Suwignyo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Master Program of History, Department of History, Faculty of Humanities, Diponegoro University 2023-01-01
Series:IHiS (Indonesian Historical Studies)
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ejournal2.undip.ac.id/index.php/ihis/article/view/16937
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832594036471365632
author Agus Suwignyo
author_facet Agus Suwignyo
author_sort Agus Suwignyo
collection DOAJ
description John F. Hartmann (1986) argued that the spread of the Indic languages in Southeast Asia took place in different overlapping periods, through which the region underwent a process of indinization. Hartmann’s thesis is very important to help understand the making of cultural networks in Southeast Asia. However, the scope of his thesis was limited by its sole focus on the Indic languages, on the mainland Southeast Asia, and on the early historic period of the region. Taking Hartmann’s thesis as a starting point, the present paper examined the spread of languages in Southeast Asia as a cultural network. By using a comparative bibliography method and by analyzing existing studies on the pre-historic and the historic stages of language development in Southeast Asia, this paper argues that the indinization as suggested by Hartmann comprised only the first phase in the overall making of the language-based cultural network in Southeast Asia. Bibliographical sources show that the language-based cultural network in Southeast Asia involved at least three other periods in addition to indinization, that is chinaization, arabization, and europeanization. In Southeast Asia, the spread of the cultural network depended not so much on a lingua franca – a language of unity – as on the plurality of languages. The successive phases in the spread of different civilizations created a Southeast Asian plural society, in which various linguistic branches molded as one of the most remarkable cultural notions of the region. Hence, the idea to have one regional language of integration, for example in the current context of ASEAN, contradicted against the cultural history of Southeast Asia. It is because Southeast Asia has become integrated through a pluralization, not unification, of languages.
format Article
id doaj-art-e15347a8efd84c9e80fa82dcd7cbaf3e
institution Kabale University
issn 2579-4213
language English
publishDate 2023-01-01
publisher Master Program of History, Department of History, Faculty of Humanities, Diponegoro University
record_format Article
series IHiS (Indonesian Historical Studies)
spelling doaj-art-e15347a8efd84c9e80fa82dcd7cbaf3e2025-01-20T06:45:56ZengMaster Program of History, Department of History, Faculty of Humanities, Diponegoro UniversityIHiS (Indonesian Historical Studies)2579-42132023-01-016220622210.14710/potensi.%Y.169377395Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s ThesisAgus Suwignyo0History Department, IndonesiaJohn F. Hartmann (1986) argued that the spread of the Indic languages in Southeast Asia took place in different overlapping periods, through which the region underwent a process of indinization. Hartmann’s thesis is very important to help understand the making of cultural networks in Southeast Asia. However, the scope of his thesis was limited by its sole focus on the Indic languages, on the mainland Southeast Asia, and on the early historic period of the region. Taking Hartmann’s thesis as a starting point, the present paper examined the spread of languages in Southeast Asia as a cultural network. By using a comparative bibliography method and by analyzing existing studies on the pre-historic and the historic stages of language development in Southeast Asia, this paper argues that the indinization as suggested by Hartmann comprised only the first phase in the overall making of the language-based cultural network in Southeast Asia. Bibliographical sources show that the language-based cultural network in Southeast Asia involved at least three other periods in addition to indinization, that is chinaization, arabization, and europeanization. In Southeast Asia, the spread of the cultural network depended not so much on a lingua franca – a language of unity – as on the plurality of languages. The successive phases in the spread of different civilizations created a Southeast Asian plural society, in which various linguistic branches molded as one of the most remarkable cultural notions of the region. Hence, the idea to have one regional language of integration, for example in the current context of ASEAN, contradicted against the cultural history of Southeast Asia. It is because Southeast Asia has become integrated through a pluralization, not unification, of languages.https://ejournal2.undip.ac.id/index.php/ihis/article/view/16937linguistic pluralitysoutheast asiacultural characteristicssocial historyjohn f. hartmann.
spellingShingle Agus Suwignyo
Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
IHiS (Indonesian Historical Studies)
linguistic plurality
southeast asia
cultural characteristics
social history
john f. hartmann.
title Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
title_full Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
title_fullStr Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
title_full_unstemmed Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
title_short Language Plurality as Cultural Characteristics of Southeast Asia: A Review of John F. Hartman’s Thesis
title_sort language plurality as cultural characteristics of southeast asia a review of john f hartman s thesis
topic linguistic plurality
southeast asia
cultural characteristics
social history
john f. hartmann.
url https://ejournal2.undip.ac.id/index.php/ihis/article/view/16937
work_keys_str_mv AT agussuwignyo languagepluralityasculturalcharacteristicsofsoutheastasiaareviewofjohnfhartmansthesis