NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY
The article explores the phenomenon of the nomenklatura as a unique socio-political institution in the context of democratic transformations within post-Soviet societies. An analysis of Mikhail Voslensky’s works reveals the mechanisms of nomenklatura functioning and aids in understanding the struct...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Russian |
| Published: |
Oles Honchar Dnipro National University
2024-12-01
|
| Series: | Епістемологічні дослідження у філософії, соціальних і політичних науках |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://visnukpfs.dp.ua/index.php/PFS/article/view/1222 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1832587033565986816 |
|---|---|
| author | Сергій САВЧЕНКО Катерина ПРОКОФ’ЄВА Оксана РЕШЕТІЛОВА |
| author_facet | Сергій САВЧЕНКО Катерина ПРОКОФ’ЄВА Оксана РЕШЕТІЛОВА |
| author_sort | Сергій САВЧЕНКО |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description |
The article explores the phenomenon of the nomenklatura as a unique socio-political institution in the context of democratic transformations within post-Soviet societies. An analysis of Mikhail Voslensky’s works reveals the mechanisms of nomenklatura functioning and aids in understanding the structural challenges of overcoming the totalitarian legacy. The core of the article focuses on a comparative analysis of Voslensky’s concept. Born in Ukraine, Voslensky had a successful career within the Soviet system before emigrating to West Germany in 1972. His seminal work, «Nomenklatura» (1980), presents a critical analysis of the revolutionary movement’s transformation into a new ruling class. Voslensky identifies the nomenklatura as a distinct class that uses a system of privileges to maintain its dominance and exert social control. He meticulously documents the institutional mechanisms of nomenklatura domination, uncovering the interplay between party hierarchy and material privileges. Particular attention is paid to the subordination of the security forces to party control through mechanisms of the Central Committee, which minimized risks to the nomenklatura system.
The article includes a comparative analysis of Voslensky’s and Milovan Djilas’s approaches to the «new class» of socialist societies. Unlike Djilas, who believed in the potential of «true» communism, Voslensky fully breaks away from the system. He refutes the thesis about the nomenklatura’s modernizing role, pointing instead to the robust developmental dynamics of pre-revolutionary Russia. The study identifies limitations and shortcomings in Voslensky’s concept. Despite his profound analysis of the Soviet nomenklatura, Voslensky failed to recognize similar mechanisms of social stratification within Western democracies. His excessive idealization of the West hindered the application of his theory to a broader context of elite formation in various state systems. Additionally, Voslensky’s research, rooted primarily in personal experience, does not adequately explore the historical and cultural nature of the nomenklatura, its genesis, or potential analogs in other systems. Nonetheless, his theoretical contributions provide a valuable foundation for developing new models of democratic governance.
|
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-db6af7cb6d1042fabfa119089bcdf942 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2618-1274 2618-1282 |
| language | Russian |
| publishDate | 2024-12-01 |
| publisher | Oles Honchar Dnipro National University |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Епістемологічні дослідження у філософії, соціальних і політичних науках |
| spelling | doaj-art-db6af7cb6d1042fabfa119089bcdf9422025-01-24T18:25:14ZrusOles Honchar Dnipro National UniversityЕпістемологічні дослідження у філософії, соціальних і політичних науках2618-12742618-12822024-12-017210.15421/342458NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKYСергій САВЧЕНКО0Катерина ПРОКОФ’ЄВА1Оксана РЕШЕТІЛОВА2Ukrainian State University of Science and TechnologyUkrainian State University of Science and TechnologyUkrainian State University of Science and Technology The article explores the phenomenon of the nomenklatura as a unique socio-political institution in the context of democratic transformations within post-Soviet societies. An analysis of Mikhail Voslensky’s works reveals the mechanisms of nomenklatura functioning and aids in understanding the structural challenges of overcoming the totalitarian legacy. The core of the article focuses on a comparative analysis of Voslensky’s concept. Born in Ukraine, Voslensky had a successful career within the Soviet system before emigrating to West Germany in 1972. His seminal work, «Nomenklatura» (1980), presents a critical analysis of the revolutionary movement’s transformation into a new ruling class. Voslensky identifies the nomenklatura as a distinct class that uses a system of privileges to maintain its dominance and exert social control. He meticulously documents the institutional mechanisms of nomenklatura domination, uncovering the interplay between party hierarchy and material privileges. Particular attention is paid to the subordination of the security forces to party control through mechanisms of the Central Committee, which minimized risks to the nomenklatura system. The article includes a comparative analysis of Voslensky’s and Milovan Djilas’s approaches to the «new class» of socialist societies. Unlike Djilas, who believed in the potential of «true» communism, Voslensky fully breaks away from the system. He refutes the thesis about the nomenklatura’s modernizing role, pointing instead to the robust developmental dynamics of pre-revolutionary Russia. The study identifies limitations and shortcomings in Voslensky’s concept. Despite his profound analysis of the Soviet nomenklatura, Voslensky failed to recognize similar mechanisms of social stratification within Western democracies. His excessive idealization of the West hindered the application of his theory to a broader context of elite formation in various state systems. Additionally, Voslensky’s research, rooted primarily in personal experience, does not adequately explore the historical and cultural nature of the nomenklatura, its genesis, or potential analogs in other systems. Nonetheless, his theoretical contributions provide a valuable foundation for developing new models of democratic governance. https://visnukpfs.dp.ua/index.php/PFS/article/view/1222nomenklatura, Mikhail Voslensky, Soviet elite, democratic transformations, totalitarian legacy, Milovan Djilas |
| spellingShingle | Сергій САВЧЕНКО Катерина ПРОКОФ’ЄВА Оксана РЕШЕТІЛОВА NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY Епістемологічні дослідження у філософії, соціальних і політичних науках nomenklatura, Mikhail Voslensky, Soviet elite, democratic transformations, totalitarian legacy, Milovan Djilas |
| title | NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY |
| title_full | NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY |
| title_fullStr | NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY |
| title_full_unstemmed | NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY |
| title_short | NEW «PARASITIC CLASS»: ON THE CONCEPT OF MIKHAIL VOSLENSKY |
| title_sort | new parasitic class on the concept of mikhail voslensky |
| topic | nomenklatura, Mikhail Voslensky, Soviet elite, democratic transformations, totalitarian legacy, Milovan Djilas |
| url | https://visnukpfs.dp.ua/index.php/PFS/article/view/1222 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT sergíjsavčenko newparasiticclassontheconceptofmikhailvoslensky AT katerinaprokofêva newparasiticclassontheconceptofmikhailvoslensky AT oksanarešetílova newparasiticclassontheconceptofmikhailvoslensky |