Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions

The study explored the proliferation and codification of discursive resources related to ambiguous arguments. This has led to a point of clarification. Marketing communication scholars have purposefully neglected the impact of ambiguous arguments, focusing instead on strategic clarity. As a result,...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Chimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu, Nor Azura Adzharuddin, Moniza Waheed, Azlina Mohd Khir, Emem Chimeziem Elijah
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: University of Johannesburg 2024-12-01
Series:Communicare
Subjects:
Online Access:https://journals.uj.ac.za/index.php/jcsa/article/view/3003
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832593887246417920
author Chimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu
Nor Azura Adzharuddin
Moniza Waheed
Azlina Mohd Khir
Emem Chimeziem Elijah
author_facet Chimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu
Nor Azura Adzharuddin
Moniza Waheed
Azlina Mohd Khir
Emem Chimeziem Elijah
author_sort Chimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu
collection DOAJ
description The study explored the proliferation and codification of discursive resources related to ambiguous arguments. This has led to a point of clarification. Marketing communication scholars have purposefully neglected the impact of ambiguous arguments, focusing instead on strategic clarity. As a result, there is a lack of conceptualisation and clarity surrounding this topic. Nonetheless, studies about ambiguous arguments are still nascent because of the overbearing criticisms that ambiguity hinders effective communication and persuasion. The study experimented to investigate the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers’ purchase decisions and demonstrated that ambiguous arguments elicit favourable purchase decisions (participants (N=260): ambiguous 130 high and 130 low). The findings reveal that highly ambiguous arguments were rated significantly more with relevance, actuality, accuracy and comprehensiveness. In addition, individuals exposed to highly ambiguous argument advertisements elicited more favourable purchase decisions than those exposed to low ambiguous argument advertisements. The findings suggest that highly ambiguous arguments (ads) undoubtedly affect consumers’ purchase decisions because of the newness, complexity and irresolvable argument presented. The motivation could not predict the relationship between ambiguous arguments and consumers’ purchase decisions. The study tested some of the key predictions of the elaboration likelihood model and strategic ambiguity model with the cues; and discovered that individuals are persuaded by central or peripheral routes based on their capacity to elaborate. The implications and future studies concerning the current theoretical framework and verifiable findings on the impacts of ambiguous arguments are carefully discussed, based on the findings.
format Article
id doaj-art-be3f1fda95394c2d8d425dd7862374ec
institution Kabale University
issn 0259-0069
2957-7950
language English
publishDate 2024-12-01
publisher University of Johannesburg
record_format Article
series Communicare
spelling doaj-art-be3f1fda95394c2d8d425dd7862374ec2025-01-20T08:39:34ZengUniversity of JohannesburgCommunicare0259-00692957-79502024-12-0143210.36615/1k83qp53Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisionsChimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu0https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8058-7707Nor Azura Adzharuddin1https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4924-1054Moniza Waheed2https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4470-1381Azlina Mohd Khir3https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8398-7653Emem Chimeziem Elijah4https://orcid.org/0009-0003-9065-7814University Putra MalaysiaUniversity PutraUniversity PutraUniversity PutraUniversity of Calabar The study explored the proliferation and codification of discursive resources related to ambiguous arguments. This has led to a point of clarification. Marketing communication scholars have purposefully neglected the impact of ambiguous arguments, focusing instead on strategic clarity. As a result, there is a lack of conceptualisation and clarity surrounding this topic. Nonetheless, studies about ambiguous arguments are still nascent because of the overbearing criticisms that ambiguity hinders effective communication and persuasion. The study experimented to investigate the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers’ purchase decisions and demonstrated that ambiguous arguments elicit favourable purchase decisions (participants (N=260): ambiguous 130 high and 130 low). The findings reveal that highly ambiguous arguments were rated significantly more with relevance, actuality, accuracy and comprehensiveness. In addition, individuals exposed to highly ambiguous argument advertisements elicited more favourable purchase decisions than those exposed to low ambiguous argument advertisements. The findings suggest that highly ambiguous arguments (ads) undoubtedly affect consumers’ purchase decisions because of the newness, complexity and irresolvable argument presented. The motivation could not predict the relationship between ambiguous arguments and consumers’ purchase decisions. The study tested some of the key predictions of the elaboration likelihood model and strategic ambiguity model with the cues; and discovered that individuals are persuaded by central or peripheral routes based on their capacity to elaborate. The implications and future studies concerning the current theoretical framework and verifiable findings on the impacts of ambiguous arguments are carefully discussed, based on the findings. https://journals.uj.ac.za/index.php/jcsa/article/view/3003Ambiguous argumentsbillboard advertisementdiscursive resourceselaboration likelihood modelstrategic ambiguity
spellingShingle Chimeziem Elijah Nwankwo-Ojionu
Nor Azura Adzharuddin
Moniza Waheed
Azlina Mohd Khir
Emem Chimeziem Elijah
Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
Communicare
Ambiguous arguments
billboard advertisement
discursive resources
elaboration likelihood model
strategic ambiguity
title Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
title_full Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
title_fullStr Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
title_full_unstemmed Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
title_short Breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers' purchase decisions
title_sort breaking through the clutter and the impact of ambiguous arguments on consumers purchase decisions
topic Ambiguous arguments
billboard advertisement
discursive resources
elaboration likelihood model
strategic ambiguity
url https://journals.uj.ac.za/index.php/jcsa/article/view/3003
work_keys_str_mv AT chimeziemelijahnwankwoojionu breakingthroughtheclutterandtheimpactofambiguousargumentsonconsumerspurchasedecisions
AT norazuraadzharuddin breakingthroughtheclutterandtheimpactofambiguousargumentsonconsumerspurchasedecisions
AT monizawaheed breakingthroughtheclutterandtheimpactofambiguousargumentsonconsumerspurchasedecisions
AT azlinamohdkhir breakingthroughtheclutterandtheimpactofambiguousargumentsonconsumerspurchasedecisions
AT ememchimeziemelijah breakingthroughtheclutterandtheimpactofambiguousargumentsonconsumerspurchasedecisions