How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review
Background: The recent COVID-19 pandemic and the emergence of infectious diseases at the human-animal interface highlight the global challenge of mitigating zoonotic risks. The One Health approach emphasizes the interconnectedness of human, animal, and environmental health, urging for holistic and i...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2024-12-01
|
| Series: | One Health |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352771424002556 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850251266036334592 |
|---|---|
| author | Caroline Kuhn Kenneth Mawuta Hayibor Ama Twumwaa Acheampong Luciana Salini Abrahão Pires Magda Clara Vieira Costa-Ribeiro María Soledad Burrone Carlos Roberto Vásquez-Almazán Katja Radon María Teresa Solis Soto Abrahão Pires Luciana Salini Adler Marcia Burrone María Soledad da Costa Ribeiro Magda Clara Vieira de Almeida Gustavo Araújo de Carvalho Denise Siqueira de Tarso Pires Paulo Encina Zamorra Veronica Garrido Marie Astrid Guzmán-Quilo Maria Carolina Kuhn Caroline Magalhães Buffon Marilene da Cruz Mansilla Vivar Pilar Macarena Mendez Heredia Dennis Martin Perez Morales Fabiana Marcela Pinto Navia Carlos Fernando Radon Katja Ribeiro de Almeida Tatjana Queiroz Solis Soto María Teresa Vásquez-Almazán Carlos Roberto |
| author_facet | Caroline Kuhn Kenneth Mawuta Hayibor Ama Twumwaa Acheampong Luciana Salini Abrahão Pires Magda Clara Vieira Costa-Ribeiro María Soledad Burrone Carlos Roberto Vásquez-Almazán Katja Radon María Teresa Solis Soto Abrahão Pires Luciana Salini Adler Marcia Burrone María Soledad da Costa Ribeiro Magda Clara Vieira de Almeida Gustavo Araújo de Carvalho Denise Siqueira de Tarso Pires Paulo Encina Zamorra Veronica Garrido Marie Astrid Guzmán-Quilo Maria Carolina Kuhn Caroline Magalhães Buffon Marilene da Cruz Mansilla Vivar Pilar Macarena Mendez Heredia Dennis Martin Perez Morales Fabiana Marcela Pinto Navia Carlos Fernando Radon Katja Ribeiro de Almeida Tatjana Queiroz Solis Soto María Teresa Vásquez-Almazán Carlos Roberto |
| author_sort | Caroline Kuhn |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Background: The recent COVID-19 pandemic and the emergence of infectious diseases at the human-animal interface highlight the global challenge of mitigating zoonotic risks. The One Health approach emphasizes the interconnectedness of human, animal, and environmental health, urging for holistic and interdisciplinary strategies in disease prevention. Despite growing interest, the attention to wildlife in pandemic prevention remains limited. This systematic literature review aims to evaluate recent One Health research on zoonotic diseases and wildlife in terms of study design, interdisciplinary collaboration, and participatory approaches. Key questions addressed include the consideration of One Health domains, disciplinary involvement, and the inclusion of non-academic stakeholders. Methods: Following PRISMA guidelines, PubMed and Web of Science were searched for primary research papers on zoonotic diseases and wildlife from 2018 to 2023. Eligibility criteria included a focus on wildlife, zoonotic diseases, and adoption of the One Health approach. Results: A total of 228 primary research papers were retrieved. Out of these, 105 studies were included in the review. Few studies integrated human, animal, and environmental domains simultaneously in data collection (4.8 %) and knowledge generation (29.5 %). While extensive knowledge was generated for animal health (97.1 %) and human health (84.8 %), environmental health (34.3 %) remained underrepresented. Laboratory methods predominated (82.9 %), with limited integration of social science methodologies (19 %). The majority were epidemiological studies (86.7 %), yet analytical design within these was sparse (17.1 %). Participation of non-academic stakeholders was limited (36.2 % included non-academics; 3.8 % encompassed participative approaches). Conclusions: The synthesis of the domains human, animal and environmental health remained fragmentary in the studies reviewed. Environmental health is underrepresented and the interdisciplinary involvement of social sciences lacks. Neglecting these fields of competence impedes comprehensive understanding of disease dynamics and hampers effective zoonosis prevention strategies. In result, greater inter- and transdisciplinary collaboration, along with participatory approaches, are still needed for advancing One Health research. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-9e9a2a00854c415fb5d75e33e202ce6a |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 2352-7714 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-12-01 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| record_format | Article |
| series | One Health |
| spelling | doaj-art-9e9a2a00854c415fb5d75e33e202ce6a2025-08-20T01:57:56ZengElsevierOne Health2352-77142024-12-011910092910.1016/j.onehlt.2024.100929How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic reviewCaroline Kuhn0Kenneth Mawuta Hayibor1Ama Twumwaa Acheampong2Luciana Salini Abrahão Pires3Magda Clara Vieira Costa-Ribeiro4María Soledad Burrone5Carlos Roberto Vásquez-Almazán6Katja Radon7María Teresa Solis Soto8Abrahão Pires Luciana SaliniAdler MarciaBurrone María Soledadda Costa Ribeiro Magda Clara Vieirade Almeida Gustavo Araújode Carvalho Denise Siqueirade Tarso Pires PauloEncina Zamorra VeronicaGarrido Marie AstridGuzmán-Quilo Maria CarolinaKuhn CarolineMagalhães Buffon Marilene da CruzMansilla Vivar Pilar MacarenaMendez Heredia Dennis MartinPerez Morales Fabiana MarcelaPinto Navia Carlos FernandoRadon KatjaRibeiro de Almeida Tatjana QueirozSolis Soto María TeresaVásquez-Almazán Carlos RobertoCenter for International Health at Ludwig-Maximilian-University Hospital, Munich, Germany; Corresponding author.Center for International Health at Ludwig-Maximilian-University Hospital, Munich, GermanyCenter for International Health at Ludwig-Maximilian-University Hospital, Munich, GermanyFederal University of Paraná, Curitiba, BrazilFederal University of Paraná, Curitiba, BrazilInstitute of Health Sciences, Universidad de O'Higgins, Rancagua, ChileMuseo de Historia Natural, Escuela de Biología, Universidad San Carlos de Guatemala, Guatemala City, GuatemalaCenter for International Health at Ludwig-Maximilian-University Hospital, Munich, GermanyInstitute of Health Sciences, Universidad de O'Higgins, Rancagua, Chile; CIHLMU OH TARGET Competence Center, Universidad San Francisco Xavier de Chuquisaca, Sucre, BoliviaBackground: The recent COVID-19 pandemic and the emergence of infectious diseases at the human-animal interface highlight the global challenge of mitigating zoonotic risks. The One Health approach emphasizes the interconnectedness of human, animal, and environmental health, urging for holistic and interdisciplinary strategies in disease prevention. Despite growing interest, the attention to wildlife in pandemic prevention remains limited. This systematic literature review aims to evaluate recent One Health research on zoonotic diseases and wildlife in terms of study design, interdisciplinary collaboration, and participatory approaches. Key questions addressed include the consideration of One Health domains, disciplinary involvement, and the inclusion of non-academic stakeholders. Methods: Following PRISMA guidelines, PubMed and Web of Science were searched for primary research papers on zoonotic diseases and wildlife from 2018 to 2023. Eligibility criteria included a focus on wildlife, zoonotic diseases, and adoption of the One Health approach. Results: A total of 228 primary research papers were retrieved. Out of these, 105 studies were included in the review. Few studies integrated human, animal, and environmental domains simultaneously in data collection (4.8 %) and knowledge generation (29.5 %). While extensive knowledge was generated for animal health (97.1 %) and human health (84.8 %), environmental health (34.3 %) remained underrepresented. Laboratory methods predominated (82.9 %), with limited integration of social science methodologies (19 %). The majority were epidemiological studies (86.7 %), yet analytical design within these was sparse (17.1 %). Participation of non-academic stakeholders was limited (36.2 % included non-academics; 3.8 % encompassed participative approaches). Conclusions: The synthesis of the domains human, animal and environmental health remained fragmentary in the studies reviewed. Environmental health is underrepresented and the interdisciplinary involvement of social sciences lacks. Neglecting these fields of competence impedes comprehensive understanding of disease dynamics and hampers effective zoonosis prevention strategies. In result, greater inter- and transdisciplinary collaboration, along with participatory approaches, are still needed for advancing One Health research.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352771424002556One healthZoonosesWild animalsInterdisciplinary research |
| spellingShingle | Caroline Kuhn Kenneth Mawuta Hayibor Ama Twumwaa Acheampong Luciana Salini Abrahão Pires Magda Clara Vieira Costa-Ribeiro María Soledad Burrone Carlos Roberto Vásquez-Almazán Katja Radon María Teresa Solis Soto Abrahão Pires Luciana Salini Adler Marcia Burrone María Soledad da Costa Ribeiro Magda Clara Vieira de Almeida Gustavo Araújo de Carvalho Denise Siqueira de Tarso Pires Paulo Encina Zamorra Veronica Garrido Marie Astrid Guzmán-Quilo Maria Carolina Kuhn Caroline Magalhães Buffon Marilene da Cruz Mansilla Vivar Pilar Macarena Mendez Heredia Dennis Martin Perez Morales Fabiana Marcela Pinto Navia Carlos Fernando Radon Katja Ribeiro de Almeida Tatjana Queiroz Solis Soto María Teresa Vásquez-Almazán Carlos Roberto How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review One Health One health Zoonoses Wild animals Interdisciplinary research |
| title | How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review |
| title_full | How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review |
| title_fullStr | How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review |
| title_full_unstemmed | How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review |
| title_short | How studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach – A systematic review |
| title_sort | how studies on zoonotic risks in wildlife implement the one health approach a systematic review |
| topic | One health Zoonoses Wild animals Interdisciplinary research |
| url | http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352771424002556 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT carolinekuhn howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT kennethmawutahayibor howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT amatwumwaaacheampong howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT lucianasaliniabrahaopires howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT magdaclaravieiracostaribeiro howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT mariasoledadburrone howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT carlosrobertovasquezalmazan howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT katjaradon howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT mariateresasolissoto howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT abrahaopireslucianasalini howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT adlermarcia howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT burronemariasoledad howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT dacostaribeiromagdaclaravieira howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT dealmeidagustavoaraujo howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT decarvalhodenisesiqueira howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT detarsopirespaulo howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT encinazamorraveronica howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT garridomarieastrid howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT guzmanquilomariacarolina howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT kuhncaroline howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT magalhaesbuffonmarilenedacruz howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT mansillavivarpilarmacarena howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT mendezherediadennismartin howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT perezmoralesfabianamarcela howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT pintonaviacarlosfernando howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT radonkatja howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT ribeirodealmeidatatjanaqueiroz howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT solissotomariateresa howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview AT vasquezalmazancarlosroberto howstudiesonzoonoticrisksinwildlifeimplementtheonehealthapproachasystematicreview |