A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study.
<h4>Background</h4>Soil-transmitted helminth (STH) control programs currently lack evidence-based recommendations for cost-efficient survey designs for monitoring and evaluation. Here, we present a framework to provide evidence-based recommendations, using a case study of therapeutic dru...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2023-05-01
|
| Series: | PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011071 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850163034173997056 |
|---|---|
| author | Luc E Coffeng Johnny Vlaminck Piet Cools Matthew Denwood Marco Albonico Shaali M Ame Mio Ayana Daniel Dana Giuseppe Cringoli Sake J de Vlas Alan Fenwick Michael French Adama Kazienga Jennifer Keiser Stefanie Knopp Gemechu Leta Leonardo F Matoso Maria P Maurelli Antonio Montresor Greg Mirams Zeleke Mekonnen Rodrigo Corrêa-Oliveira Simone A Pinto Laura Rinaldi Somphou Sayasone Peter Steinmann Eurion Thomas Jozef Vercruysse Bruno Levecke |
| author_facet | Luc E Coffeng Johnny Vlaminck Piet Cools Matthew Denwood Marco Albonico Shaali M Ame Mio Ayana Daniel Dana Giuseppe Cringoli Sake J de Vlas Alan Fenwick Michael French Adama Kazienga Jennifer Keiser Stefanie Knopp Gemechu Leta Leonardo F Matoso Maria P Maurelli Antonio Montresor Greg Mirams Zeleke Mekonnen Rodrigo Corrêa-Oliveira Simone A Pinto Laura Rinaldi Somphou Sayasone Peter Steinmann Eurion Thomas Jozef Vercruysse Bruno Levecke |
| author_sort | Luc E Coffeng |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | <h4>Background</h4>Soil-transmitted helminth (STH) control programs currently lack evidence-based recommendations for cost-efficient survey designs for monitoring and evaluation. Here, we present a framework to provide evidence-based recommendations, using a case study of therapeutic drug efficacy monitoring based on the examination of helminth eggs in stool.<h4>Methods</h4>We performed an in-depth analysis of the operational costs to process one stool sample for three diagnostic methods (Kato-Katz, Mini-FLOTAC and FECPAKG2). Next, we performed simulations to determine the probability of detecting a truly reduced therapeutic efficacy for different scenarios of STH species (Ascaris lumbricoides, Trichuris trichiura and hookworms), pre-treatment infection levels, survey design (screen and select (SS); screen, select and retest (SSR) and no selection (NS)) and number of subjects enrolled (100-5,000). Finally, we integrated the outcome of the cost assessment into the simulation study to estimate the total survey costs and determined the most cost-efficient survey design.<h4>Principal findings</h4>Kato-Katz allowed for both the highest sample throughput and the lowest cost per test, while FECPAKG2 required both the most laboratory time and was the most expensive. Counting of eggs accounted for 23% (FECPAKG2) or ≥80% (Kato-Katz and Mini-FLOTAC) of the total time-to-result. NS survey designs in combination with Kato-Katz were the most cost-efficient to assess therapeutic drug efficacy in all scenarios of STH species and endemicity.<h4>Conclusions/significance</h4>We confirm that Kato-Katz is the fecal egg counting method of choice for monitoring therapeutic drug efficacy, but that the survey design currently recommended by WHO (SS) should be updated. Our generic framework, which captures laboratory time and material costs, can be used to further support cost-efficient choices for other important surveys informing STH control programs. In addition, it can be used to explore the value of alternative diagnostic techniques, like automated egg counting, which may further reduce operational costs.<h4>Trial registration</h4>ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03465488. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-959546d352cb4673b3dd07a62f24a5e7 |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 1935-2727 1935-2735 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2023-05-01 |
| publisher | Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
| record_format | Article |
| series | PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| spelling | doaj-art-959546d352cb4673b3dd07a62f24a5e72025-08-20T02:22:24ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases1935-27271935-27352023-05-01175e001107110.1371/journal.pntd.0011071A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study.Luc E CoffengJohnny VlaminckPiet CoolsMatthew DenwoodMarco AlbonicoShaali M AmeMio AyanaDaniel DanaGiuseppe CringoliSake J de VlasAlan FenwickMichael FrenchAdama KaziengaJennifer KeiserStefanie KnoppGemechu LetaLeonardo F MatosoMaria P MaurelliAntonio MontresorGreg MiramsZeleke MekonnenRodrigo Corrêa-OliveiraSimone A PintoLaura RinaldiSomphou SayasonePeter SteinmannEurion ThomasJozef VercruysseBruno Levecke<h4>Background</h4>Soil-transmitted helminth (STH) control programs currently lack evidence-based recommendations for cost-efficient survey designs for monitoring and evaluation. Here, we present a framework to provide evidence-based recommendations, using a case study of therapeutic drug efficacy monitoring based on the examination of helminth eggs in stool.<h4>Methods</h4>We performed an in-depth analysis of the operational costs to process one stool sample for three diagnostic methods (Kato-Katz, Mini-FLOTAC and FECPAKG2). Next, we performed simulations to determine the probability of detecting a truly reduced therapeutic efficacy for different scenarios of STH species (Ascaris lumbricoides, Trichuris trichiura and hookworms), pre-treatment infection levels, survey design (screen and select (SS); screen, select and retest (SSR) and no selection (NS)) and number of subjects enrolled (100-5,000). Finally, we integrated the outcome of the cost assessment into the simulation study to estimate the total survey costs and determined the most cost-efficient survey design.<h4>Principal findings</h4>Kato-Katz allowed for both the highest sample throughput and the lowest cost per test, while FECPAKG2 required both the most laboratory time and was the most expensive. Counting of eggs accounted for 23% (FECPAKG2) or ≥80% (Kato-Katz and Mini-FLOTAC) of the total time-to-result. NS survey designs in combination with Kato-Katz were the most cost-efficient to assess therapeutic drug efficacy in all scenarios of STH species and endemicity.<h4>Conclusions/significance</h4>We confirm that Kato-Katz is the fecal egg counting method of choice for monitoring therapeutic drug efficacy, but that the survey design currently recommended by WHO (SS) should be updated. Our generic framework, which captures laboratory time and material costs, can be used to further support cost-efficient choices for other important surveys informing STH control programs. In addition, it can be used to explore the value of alternative diagnostic techniques, like automated egg counting, which may further reduce operational costs.<h4>Trial registration</h4>ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03465488.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011071 |
| spellingShingle | Luc E Coffeng Johnny Vlaminck Piet Cools Matthew Denwood Marco Albonico Shaali M Ame Mio Ayana Daniel Dana Giuseppe Cringoli Sake J de Vlas Alan Fenwick Michael French Adama Kazienga Jennifer Keiser Stefanie Knopp Gemechu Leta Leonardo F Matoso Maria P Maurelli Antonio Montresor Greg Mirams Zeleke Mekonnen Rodrigo Corrêa-Oliveira Simone A Pinto Laura Rinaldi Somphou Sayasone Peter Steinmann Eurion Thomas Jozef Vercruysse Bruno Levecke A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases |
| title | A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. |
| title_full | A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. |
| title_fullStr | A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. |
| title_full_unstemmed | A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. |
| title_short | A general framework to support cost-efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large-scale STH deworming programs-monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study. |
| title_sort | general framework to support cost efficient fecal egg count methods and study design choices for large scale sth deworming programs monitoring of therapeutic drug efficacy as a case study |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011071 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT lucecoffeng ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT johnnyvlaminck ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT pietcools ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT matthewdenwood ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT marcoalbonico ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT shaalimame ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT mioayana ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT danieldana ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT giuseppecringoli ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT sakejdevlas ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT alanfenwick ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT michaelfrench ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT adamakazienga ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT jenniferkeiser ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT stefanieknopp ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT gemechuleta ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT leonardofmatoso ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT mariapmaurelli ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT antoniomontresor ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT gregmirams ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT zelekemekonnen ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT rodrigocorreaoliveira ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT simoneapinto ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT laurarinaldi ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT somphousayasone ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT petersteinmann ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT eurionthomas ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT jozefvercruysse ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT brunolevecke ageneralframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT lucecoffeng generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT johnnyvlaminck generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT pietcools generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT matthewdenwood generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT marcoalbonico generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT shaalimame generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT mioayana generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT danieldana generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT giuseppecringoli generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT sakejdevlas generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT alanfenwick generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT michaelfrench generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT adamakazienga generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT jenniferkeiser generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT stefanieknopp generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT gemechuleta generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT leonardofmatoso generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT mariapmaurelli generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT antoniomontresor generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT gregmirams generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT zelekemekonnen generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT rodrigocorreaoliveira generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT simoneapinto generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT laurarinaldi generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT somphousayasone generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT petersteinmann generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT eurionthomas generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT jozefvercruysse generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy AT brunolevecke generalframeworktosupportcostefficientfecaleggcountmethodsandstudydesignchoicesforlargescalesthdewormingprogramsmonitoringoftherapeuticdrugefficacyasacasestudy |