Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience

Abstract Background HIV burden remains high in South Africa despite intensive efforts to curtail the epidemic. Public primary care facilities, where most people with HIV (PWH) in South Africa receive treatment, face myriad challenges retaining patients on antiretroviral therapy (ART). Nevertheless,...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Allison J. Ober, Donald H. Skinner, Laura M. Bogart, Leletu Busakwe, Wadene Davids, Hassan Mahomed, Debbie Ling, Virginia Zweigenthal
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2025-02-01
Series:BMC Global and Public Health
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1186/s44263-025-00123-3
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1823861481125445632
author Allison J. Ober
Donald H. Skinner
Laura M. Bogart
Leletu Busakwe
Wadene Davids
Hassan Mahomed
Debbie Ling
Virginia Zweigenthal
author_facet Allison J. Ober
Donald H. Skinner
Laura M. Bogart
Leletu Busakwe
Wadene Davids
Hassan Mahomed
Debbie Ling
Virginia Zweigenthal
author_sort Allison J. Ober
collection DOAJ
description Abstract Background HIV burden remains high in South Africa despite intensive efforts to curtail the epidemic. Public primary care facilities, where most people with HIV (PWH) in South Africa receive treatment, face myriad challenges retaining patients on antiretroviral therapy (ART). Nevertheless, some facilities manage to consistently retain PWH in care. We used a participatory positive deviance (PD) approach to discover characteristics of primary care facilities with above-average 12-month retention rates to develop an intervention. Methods We conducted 11 in-depth leadership interviews, 9 staff focus groups with 29 participants, 11 patient focus groups with 45 participants, 23 patient shadowing visits, and multiple facility observations in each of 3 high- and 3 low-retention public primary care facilities in Cape Town, South Africa. Using PD, an asset-based approach to behavior change that consists of discovering how high-performing outliers succeed despite sizable barriers, and then using those data to develop interventions for low performers, we analyzed data to discover dominant characteristics of higher-retention facilities that might be contributing to higher retention rates. Results Dominant themes found in higher-retention facilities were compassionate, respectful, and patient-centered care; higher staff morale, passion for the work, and team cohesion; efficient workflow procedures; and a welcoming physical environment. From these themes, we developed the multidimensional Connect intervention, consisting of strategies within three domains: (1) engage, encourage, and support staff (e.g., a monthly staff support huddle, a compassion training); (2) expedite and augment workflow procedures (e.g., adjust folder system to lower wait times); and (3) create a welcoming physical environment (e.g., fresh paint and plants in the waiting area). Conclusions A PD approach enabled us to identify factors that could be contributing to higher ART retention rates within low-resource public sector primary care facilities in Cape Town, South Africa, and to develop a multidimensional intervention. If effective after a future trial, the intervention could be a feasible, affordable complement to existing programs aimed at improving care for PWH.
format Article
id doaj-art-87e400c04a6a435ebd2b09215f4ffbf7
institution Kabale University
issn 2731-913X
language English
publishDate 2025-02-01
publisher BMC
record_format Article
series BMC Global and Public Health
spelling doaj-art-87e400c04a6a435ebd2b09215f4ffbf72025-02-09T13:00:37ZengBMCBMC Global and Public Health2731-913X2025-02-013111310.1186/s44263-025-00123-3Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experienceAllison J. Ober0Donald H. Skinner1Laura M. Bogart2Leletu Busakwe3Wadene Davids4Hassan Mahomed5Debbie Ling6Virginia Zweigenthal7RANDDepartment of Global Health, Stellenbosch UniversityRANDDepartment of Global Health, Stellenbosch UniversityDepartment of Global Health, Stellenbosch UniversityWestern Cape Department of Health and WellnessDepartment of Social Work, Monash UniversityUniversity of Cape TownAbstract Background HIV burden remains high in South Africa despite intensive efforts to curtail the epidemic. Public primary care facilities, where most people with HIV (PWH) in South Africa receive treatment, face myriad challenges retaining patients on antiretroviral therapy (ART). Nevertheless, some facilities manage to consistently retain PWH in care. We used a participatory positive deviance (PD) approach to discover characteristics of primary care facilities with above-average 12-month retention rates to develop an intervention. Methods We conducted 11 in-depth leadership interviews, 9 staff focus groups with 29 participants, 11 patient focus groups with 45 participants, 23 patient shadowing visits, and multiple facility observations in each of 3 high- and 3 low-retention public primary care facilities in Cape Town, South Africa. Using PD, an asset-based approach to behavior change that consists of discovering how high-performing outliers succeed despite sizable barriers, and then using those data to develop interventions for low performers, we analyzed data to discover dominant characteristics of higher-retention facilities that might be contributing to higher retention rates. Results Dominant themes found in higher-retention facilities were compassionate, respectful, and patient-centered care; higher staff morale, passion for the work, and team cohesion; efficient workflow procedures; and a welcoming physical environment. From these themes, we developed the multidimensional Connect intervention, consisting of strategies within three domains: (1) engage, encourage, and support staff (e.g., a monthly staff support huddle, a compassion training); (2) expedite and augment workflow procedures (e.g., adjust folder system to lower wait times); and (3) create a welcoming physical environment (e.g., fresh paint and plants in the waiting area). Conclusions A PD approach enabled us to identify factors that could be contributing to higher ART retention rates within low-resource public sector primary care facilities in Cape Town, South Africa, and to develop a multidimensional intervention. If effective after a future trial, the intervention could be a feasible, affordable complement to existing programs aimed at improving care for PWH.https://doi.org/10.1186/s44263-025-00123-3ART/ARV retentionHIV carePositive devianceSouth AfricaCompassionate carePatient-centered care
spellingShingle Allison J. Ober
Donald H. Skinner
Laura M. Bogart
Leletu Busakwe
Wadene Davids
Hassan Mahomed
Debbie Ling
Virginia Zweigenthal
Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
BMC Global and Public Health
ART/ARV retention
HIV care
Positive deviance
South Africa
Compassionate care
Patient-centered care
title Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
title_full Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
title_fullStr Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
title_full_unstemmed Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
title_short Using positive deviance to enhance HIV care retention in South Africa: development of a compassion-focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
title_sort using positive deviance to enhance hiv care retention in south africa development of a compassion focused program to improve the staff and patient experience
topic ART/ARV retention
HIV care
Positive deviance
South Africa
Compassionate care
Patient-centered care
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s44263-025-00123-3
work_keys_str_mv AT allisonjober usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT donaldhskinner usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT laurambogart usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT leletubusakwe usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT wadenedavids usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT hassanmahomed usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT debbieling usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience
AT virginiazweigenthal usingpositivedeviancetoenhancehivcareretentioninsouthafricadevelopmentofacompassionfocusedprogramtoimprovethestaffandpatientexperience