Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel

This essay shows how poetical elements may be integrated to a prose genre, the crime fiction narrative, and the perturbations they may generate. Conan Doyle’s Musgrave Ritual centers on a pattern of verse. There are two ways of interpreting it: a poetical reading, that denies the text an object, and...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Camille Fort-Cantoni
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Centre de Recherche "Texte et Critique de Texte" 2004-12-01
Series:Sillages Critiques
Subjects:
Online Access:https://journals.openedition.org/sillagescritiques/1438
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832578497432780800
author Camille Fort-Cantoni
author_facet Camille Fort-Cantoni
author_sort Camille Fort-Cantoni
collection DOAJ
description This essay shows how poetical elements may be integrated to a prose genre, the crime fiction narrative, and the perturbations they may generate. Conan Doyle’s Musgrave Ritual centers on a pattern of verse. There are two ways of interpreting it: a poetical reading, that denies the text an object, and an utilitarian reading, that forces out of it a series of names limiting its “effect of illimitation” (Jean Cohen), though questioned by narrative irony. In Agatha Christie’s Crooked House, the nursery rhyme in the title is merely submitted by the detective to a rational, analogical reading. Now an irrational reading, based on Freud’s interpretation of dreams, might show that the poem’s signifiers all reveal one unspeakable statement: a child has killed. In Colin Dexter’s The Way Through The Woods, a detective builds up a poem in order to display its object – a corpse. This interpretation happens to be faulty, yet the poem states the truth insofar as it expresses another murderer’s confession – unknown to his author and the murderer. An oracular utterance, it subverts the traditional pattern of the detective’s final explanation.
format Article
id doaj-art-7c8f5c3f830b4fdb9c330b6086a7b6a8
institution Kabale University
issn 1272-3819
1969-6302
language English
publishDate 2004-12-01
publisher Centre de Recherche "Texte et Critique de Texte"
record_format Article
series Sillages Critiques
spelling doaj-art-7c8f5c3f830b4fdb9c330b6086a7b6a82025-01-30T13:48:13ZengCentre de Recherche "Texte et Critique de Texte"Sillages Critiques1272-38191969-63022004-12-016455610.4000/sillagescritiques.1438Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime NovelCamille Fort-CantoniThis essay shows how poetical elements may be integrated to a prose genre, the crime fiction narrative, and the perturbations they may generate. Conan Doyle’s Musgrave Ritual centers on a pattern of verse. There are two ways of interpreting it: a poetical reading, that denies the text an object, and an utilitarian reading, that forces out of it a series of names limiting its “effect of illimitation” (Jean Cohen), though questioned by narrative irony. In Agatha Christie’s Crooked House, the nursery rhyme in the title is merely submitted by the detective to a rational, analogical reading. Now an irrational reading, based on Freud’s interpretation of dreams, might show that the poem’s signifiers all reveal one unspeakable statement: a child has killed. In Colin Dexter’s The Way Through The Woods, a detective builds up a poem in order to display its object – a corpse. This interpretation happens to be faulty, yet the poem states the truth insofar as it expresses another murderer’s confession – unknown to his author and the murderer. An oracular utterance, it subverts the traditional pattern of the detective’s final explanation.https://journals.openedition.org/sillagescritiques/1438poetryConan DoyleAgatha ChristieColin Dextercrime fictioninterpretation
spellingShingle Camille Fort-Cantoni
Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
Sillages Critiques
poetry
Conan Doyle
Agatha Christie
Colin Dexter
crime fiction
interpretation
title Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
title_full Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
title_fullStr Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
title_full_unstemmed Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
title_short Rhyme or Reason: Three Patterns of Poetic Interference in the British Crime Novel
title_sort rhyme or reason three patterns of poetic interference in the british crime novel
topic poetry
Conan Doyle
Agatha Christie
Colin Dexter
crime fiction
interpretation
url https://journals.openedition.org/sillagescritiques/1438
work_keys_str_mv AT camillefortcantoni rhymeorreasonthreepatternsofpoeticinterferenceinthebritishcrimenovel