De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien

The New Deal was the first major reformist experiment in the history of the United States that was neither inspired nor supported by Protestantism. While a majority of Protestants and their clergy opposed Franklin Roosevelt from a conservative position, the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr developed a vi...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Isabelle Richet
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Association Française d'Etudes Américaines 2006-03-01
Series:Transatlantica
Subjects:
Online Access:https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/178
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832580625484218368
author Isabelle Richet
author_facet Isabelle Richet
author_sort Isabelle Richet
collection DOAJ
description The New Deal was the first major reformist experiment in the history of the United States that was neither inspired nor supported by Protestantism. While a majority of Protestants and their clergy opposed Franklin Roosevelt from a conservative position, the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr developed a virulent left‑wing criticism of his policies, before finally rallying to his support at the end of the decade. Rejecting the idealism of the Social Gospel, unable to understand social relationships in term of class interests and power, Niebuhr used Marx’s analytical tools to develop a more realistic and efficient political approach. He saw the New Deal as a program aiming to save capitalism through state action, whereas the society based on social justice that he envisaged required the socialisation of the means of production which could be brought about only through social conflicts that may require the use of violence. However, under the influence of events in Europe after the rise of Hitler to power, he turned increasingly to theology. Inspired by the neo‑orthodoxy of Karl Barth and of his own brother, Richard Niebuhr, he reintroduced sin as the absolute limit of human action. Because of man’s sinful nature it was impossible to create a society based on justice and peace. His new theological absolutism led to political relativism. Indeed, realism now meant that in politics a Christian could only choose between the lesser of two evils. From this point of view the Democratic president and his preparedness campaign appeared as the only realistic choice in the context of the rise of fascism in Europe.
format Article
id doaj-art-77d56374a3d045a99558de8613b0049a
institution Kabale University
issn 1765-2766
language English
publishDate 2006-03-01
publisher Association Française d'Etudes Américaines
record_format Article
series Transatlantica
spelling doaj-art-77d56374a3d045a99558de8613b0049a2025-01-30T10:47:33ZengAssociation Française d'Etudes AméricainesTransatlantica1765-27662006-03-01110.4000/transatlantica.178De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétienIsabelle RichetThe New Deal was the first major reformist experiment in the history of the United States that was neither inspired nor supported by Protestantism. While a majority of Protestants and their clergy opposed Franklin Roosevelt from a conservative position, the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr developed a virulent left‑wing criticism of his policies, before finally rallying to his support at the end of the decade. Rejecting the idealism of the Social Gospel, unable to understand social relationships in term of class interests and power, Niebuhr used Marx’s analytical tools to develop a more realistic and efficient political approach. He saw the New Deal as a program aiming to save capitalism through state action, whereas the society based on social justice that he envisaged required the socialisation of the means of production which could be brought about only through social conflicts that may require the use of violence. However, under the influence of events in Europe after the rise of Hitler to power, he turned increasingly to theology. Inspired by the neo‑orthodoxy of Karl Barth and of his own brother, Richard Niebuhr, he reintroduced sin as the absolute limit of human action. Because of man’s sinful nature it was impossible to create a society based on justice and peace. His new theological absolutism led to political relativism. Indeed, realism now meant that in politics a Christian could only choose between the lesser of two evils. From this point of view the Democratic president and his preparedness campaign appeared as the only realistic choice in the context of the rise of fascism in Europe.https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/178Reinhold NiebuhrSocial GospelLiberal ProtestantismRadicalismChristian realism
spellingShingle Isabelle Richet
De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
Transatlantica
Reinhold Niebuhr
Social Gospel
Liberal Protestantism
Radicalism
Christian realism
title De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
title_full De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
title_fullStr De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
title_full_unstemmed De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
title_short De l’utopie socialiste au réalisme chrétien
title_sort de l utopie socialiste au realisme chretien
topic Reinhold Niebuhr
Social Gospel
Liberal Protestantism
Radicalism
Christian realism
url https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/178
work_keys_str_mv AT isabellerichet delutopiesocialisteaurealismechretien