Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County
From 22:00 on September 6， 2023 to 04:00 （Beijing Time） on September 7， Xiahe County in Gansu Province experienced severe convective weather， with short-term heavy rainfall in some areas， causing flash floods in Guoning Village， Xiahe County， resulting in casualties.In this study， the characteristic...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | zho |
| Published: |
Science Press, PR China
2025-02-01
|
| Series: | Gaoyuan qixiang |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://www.gyqx.ac.cn/EN/10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2024.00065 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850085684650442752 |
|---|---|
| author | Wubin HUANG Jing FU Runxia GUO Junxia ZHANG Yu LEI |
| author_facet | Wubin HUANG Jing FU Runxia GUO Junxia ZHANG Yu LEI |
| author_sort | Wubin HUANG |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | From 22:00 on September 6， 2023 to 04:00 （Beijing Time） on September 7， Xiahe County in Gansu Province experienced severe convective weather， with short-term heavy rainfall in some areas， causing flash floods in Guoning Village， Xiahe County， resulting in casualties.In this study， the characteristics of Radar Quantitative Precipitation Estimation （Radar-QPE）， FengYun 4B Quantitative Precipitation Estimation （FY4B-QPE）， and CMA Multi-source Precipitation Analysis （CMPA） precipitation products were contrastive analyzed based on meteorological station observations.These precipitation data were used to drive the hydrodynamic hydrological model and evaluate the effect of different precipitation data in the flash flood simulation.The results showed that： （1） Among the 12-hour cumulative precipitation amounts， CMPA demonstrated higher accuracy in terms of the position of large value areas and differences in local precipitation levels； Radar-QPE was closer to AWS （Automatic Weather Station） in terms of cumulative precipitation level but showed significant differences in spatial distribution； FY4B-QPE overestimated the cumulative precipitation level by 33.8%.（2） In terms of hourly distribution， CMPA was most similar to AWS in terms of temporal evolution， spatial distribution， and precipitation level； Radar-QPE's peak values were smaller， and the peak times were lagged， with negative deviations in precipitation being dominant； FY4B-QPE's peak values and peak times were consistent with reality， but there were deviations in the start and end times of precipitation， with positive deviations in precipitation being dominant.（3） In the hydrological simulation study， CMPA， Radar-QPE， and FY4B-QPE all overestimated water levels， but the timing of water level peaks was more consistent with AWS.CMPA performed best in terms of RMSE （Root Mean Square Error）， NSE （Nash Efficiency Coefficient）， and Bias （Relative Deviation）， followed by Radar-QPE， and FY4B-QPE performed relatively poorly.Although existing site-observed precipitation cannot fully meet the needs of research and early warning for small and medium scale mountain floods， the high precision of CMPA data could effectively supplement the deficiencies of traditional meteorological observation stations to some extent.Meanwhile， the algorithms and accuracy of Radar-QPE and FY4B-QPE needed to be further improved and enhanced. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-6cf2a8c839794355896d82c4f045a236 |
| institution | DOAJ |
| issn | 1000-0534 |
| language | zho |
| publishDate | 2025-02-01 |
| publisher | Science Press, PR China |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Gaoyuan qixiang |
| spelling | doaj-art-6cf2a8c839794355896d82c4f045a2362025-08-20T02:43:39ZzhoScience Press, PR ChinaGaoyuan qixiang1000-05342025-02-0144111012110.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2024.000651000-0534（2025）01-0110-12Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe CountyWubin HUANG0Jing FU1Runxia GUO2Junxia ZHANG3Yu LEI4Lanzhou Central Meteorological Observatory， Lanzhou 730020， Gansu， ChinaLanzhou Central Meteorological Observatory， Lanzhou 730020， Gansu， ChinaLanzhou Central Meteorological Observatory， Lanzhou 730020， Gansu， ChinaLanzhou Central Meteorological Observatory， Lanzhou 730020， Gansu， ChinaMeteorological Bureau of Lanzhou， Lanzhou 730020， Gansu， ChinaFrom 22:00 on September 6， 2023 to 04:00 （Beijing Time） on September 7， Xiahe County in Gansu Province experienced severe convective weather， with short-term heavy rainfall in some areas， causing flash floods in Guoning Village， Xiahe County， resulting in casualties.In this study， the characteristics of Radar Quantitative Precipitation Estimation （Radar-QPE）， FengYun 4B Quantitative Precipitation Estimation （FY4B-QPE）， and CMA Multi-source Precipitation Analysis （CMPA） precipitation products were contrastive analyzed based on meteorological station observations.These precipitation data were used to drive the hydrodynamic hydrological model and evaluate the effect of different precipitation data in the flash flood simulation.The results showed that： （1） Among the 12-hour cumulative precipitation amounts， CMPA demonstrated higher accuracy in terms of the position of large value areas and differences in local precipitation levels； Radar-QPE was closer to AWS （Automatic Weather Station） in terms of cumulative precipitation level but showed significant differences in spatial distribution； FY4B-QPE overestimated the cumulative precipitation level by 33.8%.（2） In terms of hourly distribution， CMPA was most similar to AWS in terms of temporal evolution， spatial distribution， and precipitation level； Radar-QPE's peak values were smaller， and the peak times were lagged， with negative deviations in precipitation being dominant； FY4B-QPE's peak values and peak times were consistent with reality， but there were deviations in the start and end times of precipitation， with positive deviations in precipitation being dominant.（3） In the hydrological simulation study， CMPA， Radar-QPE， and FY4B-QPE all overestimated water levels， but the timing of water level peaks was more consistent with AWS.CMPA performed best in terms of RMSE （Root Mean Square Error）， NSE （Nash Efficiency Coefficient）， and Bias （Relative Deviation）， followed by Radar-QPE， and FY4B-QPE performed relatively poorly.Although existing site-observed precipitation cannot fully meet the needs of research and early warning for small and medium scale mountain floods， the high precision of CMPA data could effectively supplement the deficiencies of traditional meteorological observation stations to some extent.Meanwhile， the algorithms and accuracy of Radar-QPE and FY4B-QPE needed to be further improved and enhanced.http://www.gyqx.ac.cn/EN/10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2024.00065multiple precipitationtorrential floodcmparadar-qpefy4b-qpe |
| spellingShingle | Wubin HUANG Jing FU Runxia GUO Junxia ZHANG Yu LEI Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County Gaoyuan qixiang multiple precipitation torrential flood cmpa radar-qpe fy4b-qpe |
| title | Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County |
| title_full | Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County |
| title_fullStr | Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County |
| title_full_unstemmed | Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County |
| title_short | Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Precipitation Data in Mountain Flood Simulation in Guoning Village， Xiahe County |
| title_sort | accuracy evaluation of multi source precipitation data in mountain flood simulation in guoning village xiahe county |
| topic | multiple precipitation torrential flood cmpa radar-qpe fy4b-qpe |
| url | http://www.gyqx.ac.cn/EN/10.7522/j.issn.1000-0534.2024.00065 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT wubinhuang accuracyevaluationofmultisourceprecipitationdatainmountainfloodsimulationinguoningvillagexiahecounty AT jingfu accuracyevaluationofmultisourceprecipitationdatainmountainfloodsimulationinguoningvillagexiahecounty AT runxiaguo accuracyevaluationofmultisourceprecipitationdatainmountainfloodsimulationinguoningvillagexiahecounty AT junxiazhang accuracyevaluationofmultisourceprecipitationdatainmountainfloodsimulationinguoningvillagexiahecounty AT yulei accuracyevaluationofmultisourceprecipitationdatainmountainfloodsimulationinguoningvillagexiahecounty |