Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021

Tobacco content on Twitter (X) generally opposes regulation. Although a near real-time data source of the public’s response to prominent events heightens the allure of extrapolating public sentiment from Twitter content, tobacco policy sentiment on the platform may be more indicative of industry-aff...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Nathan A. Silver, Miao Feng, Elexis C. Kierstead, Hy Tran, Steven Binns, Sherry Emery, Barbara A. Schillo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SAGE Publishing 2025-01-01
Series:Social Media + Society
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051251314611
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832584724099366912
author Nathan A. Silver
Miao Feng
Elexis C. Kierstead
Hy Tran
Steven Binns
Sherry Emery
Barbara A. Schillo
author_facet Nathan A. Silver
Miao Feng
Elexis C. Kierstead
Hy Tran
Steven Binns
Sherry Emery
Barbara A. Schillo
author_sort Nathan A. Silver
collection DOAJ
description Tobacco content on Twitter (X) generally opposes regulation. Although a near real-time data source of the public’s response to prominent events heightens the allure of extrapolating public sentiment from Twitter content, tobacco policy sentiment on the platform may be more indicative of industry-affiliated top users. We examined 2 years of tobacco policy discussion on Twitter (X) at the user level ( N  = 3,159,807 posts) from September 2019 to July 2021. We sampled the 100 most followed, amplified (retweets), influential (H index), and connected (betweenness centrality) users at three different time periods: pre-COVID (September 2019 to February 2020), COVID lockdown (March 2020 to March 2021), and post vaccine rollout (April to July 2021) to characterize top users. The Louvain method was used to partition users into communities based on retweet behavior. The 100 most amplified users received between 48% and 71% of all retweets across time periods, with e-cigarette advocates dominating the most amplified (64.7%), influential (38.4%) and connected users (42.1%). The vast majority of interaction took place in communities dominated by e-cigarette advocates, but only reaching 2.5% to 8.2% of users. We identified 58 tobacco policy top users who had 1,000 or more total retweets and were among the top 100 for any of our influence metrics at more than one time period. Among top users, 50 were e-cigarette advocates, and 24 had quantifiable ties to the tobacco industry. Practitioners and researchers should be wary of mischaracterizing industry public relations on social media as public sentiment.
format Article
id doaj-art-5ec685b51efc4def85273a8c4a8b2e89
institution Kabale University
issn 2056-3051
language English
publishDate 2025-01-01
publisher SAGE Publishing
record_format Article
series Social Media + Society
spelling doaj-art-5ec685b51efc4def85273a8c4a8b2e892025-01-27T12:04:19ZengSAGE PublishingSocial Media + Society2056-30512025-01-011110.1177/20563051251314611Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021Nathan A. Silver0Miao Feng1Elexis C. Kierstead2Hy Tran3Steven Binns4Sherry Emery5Barbara A. Schillo6Truth Initiative Schroeder Institute, USAThe University of Chicago, USATruth Initiative Schroeder Institute, USAThe University of Chicago, USAThe University of Chicago, USAThe University of Chicago, USATruth Initiative Schroeder Institute, USATobacco content on Twitter (X) generally opposes regulation. Although a near real-time data source of the public’s response to prominent events heightens the allure of extrapolating public sentiment from Twitter content, tobacco policy sentiment on the platform may be more indicative of industry-affiliated top users. We examined 2 years of tobacco policy discussion on Twitter (X) at the user level ( N  = 3,159,807 posts) from September 2019 to July 2021. We sampled the 100 most followed, amplified (retweets), influential (H index), and connected (betweenness centrality) users at three different time periods: pre-COVID (September 2019 to February 2020), COVID lockdown (March 2020 to March 2021), and post vaccine rollout (April to July 2021) to characterize top users. The Louvain method was used to partition users into communities based on retweet behavior. The 100 most amplified users received between 48% and 71% of all retweets across time periods, with e-cigarette advocates dominating the most amplified (64.7%), influential (38.4%) and connected users (42.1%). The vast majority of interaction took place in communities dominated by e-cigarette advocates, but only reaching 2.5% to 8.2% of users. We identified 58 tobacco policy top users who had 1,000 or more total retweets and were among the top 100 for any of our influence metrics at more than one time period. Among top users, 50 were e-cigarette advocates, and 24 had quantifiable ties to the tobacco industry. Practitioners and researchers should be wary of mischaracterizing industry public relations on social media as public sentiment.https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051251314611
spellingShingle Nathan A. Silver
Miao Feng
Elexis C. Kierstead
Hy Tran
Steven Binns
Sherry Emery
Barbara A. Schillo
Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
Social Media + Society
title Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
title_full Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
title_fullStr Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
title_full_unstemmed Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
title_short Twitter (X) and the Commercial Determinants of Health: Characterizing the Most Amplified, Influential, and Connected Voices Driving Twitter Discourse About Tobacco Regulatory Policy From September 2019 to July 2021
title_sort twitter x and the commercial determinants of health characterizing the most amplified influential and connected voices driving twitter discourse about tobacco regulatory policy from september 2019 to july 2021
url https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051251314611
work_keys_str_mv AT nathanasilver twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT miaofeng twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT elexisckierstead twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT hytran twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT stevenbinns twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT sherryemery twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021
AT barbaraaschillo twitterxandthecommercialdeterminantsofhealthcharacterizingthemostamplifiedinfluentialandconnectedvoicesdrivingtwitterdiscourseabouttobaccoregulatorypolicyfromseptember2019tojuly2021