Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines

About twenty years ago, Robert Darnton famously wrote about how books know no frontiers. Nevertheless, as the discipline of book history has established itself around the world, many comprehensive works on the research field have determined themselves according to the nation-state borders. As natio...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Jyrki Hakapää
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Vilnius University Press 2024-08-01
Series:Knygotyra
Subjects:
-
Online Access:https://www.journals.vu.lt/knygotyra/article/view/36284
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832593342738726912
author Jyrki Hakapää
author_facet Jyrki Hakapää
author_sort Jyrki Hakapää
collection DOAJ
description About twenty years ago, Robert Darnton famously wrote about how books know no frontiers. Nevertheless, as the discipline of book history has established itself around the world, many comprehensive works on the research field have determined themselves according to the nation-state borders. As national needs have been recently fulfilled in many countries, international and cosmopolitan themes and studies have received a new kind of support. In a world marked by globalization, such a change in attitude seems reasonable. Those book historians who hear the call must determine their research work anew and find new, interesting frameworks for their studies. What can they find? What possibilities do these new choices offer? The international approaches may offer new insights about the past, but do they also offer better chances to secure project funding and reach contemporary readers? Researchers in smaller countries, where local book culture has been more or less dependent on foreign contacts and influences for a long time, might question if the cosmopolitan attitude has ever truly been forgotten. A new methodological turn towards transnationalism and diversity might seem less relevant when looking for examples from the Baltic Sea region, where languages, cultural and trade networks, social systems, and even states have continuously changed. In the end, contemporary book history researchers do not only have to answer whether they want to follow new methodological suggestions but also what they want to seek when examining history. The presentation discusses three topics related to the recent methodological trend that seeks to move beyond nation-states as the main object or framework of book history studies. First, the juxtaposition between national and international approaches is examined. Additionally, other concepts like "local," "regional," "domestic," "transnational," and "multinational" are conceptualized and compared to each other. Secondly, researchers should seek alternative defining frameworks: studies focusing on linguistic, social, or gender borders, rather than a national approach, would offer further insights. Finally, specific methodologies have been created for international history studies; comparative studies, studies on cultural transfer, and entangled histories all reveal different aspects of examined societies and individuals. They all belong to historians' working tools.
format Article
id doaj-art-5c7b507dd20941d0a2d5c8d8f7c2e69a
institution Kabale University
issn 0204-2061
2345-0053
language English
publishDate 2024-08-01
publisher Vilnius University Press
record_format Article
series Knygotyra
spelling doaj-art-5c7b507dd20941d0a2d5c8d8f7c2e69a2025-01-20T18:10:25ZengVilnius University PressKnygotyra0204-20612345-00532024-08-014410.15388/Knygotyra.44.19Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlinesJyrki Hakapää About twenty years ago, Robert Darnton famously wrote about how books know no frontiers. Nevertheless, as the discipline of book history has established itself around the world, many comprehensive works on the research field have determined themselves according to the nation-state borders. As national needs have been recently fulfilled in many countries, international and cosmopolitan themes and studies have received a new kind of support. In a world marked by globalization, such a change in attitude seems reasonable. Those book historians who hear the call must determine their research work anew and find new, interesting frameworks for their studies. What can they find? What possibilities do these new choices offer? The international approaches may offer new insights about the past, but do they also offer better chances to secure project funding and reach contemporary readers? Researchers in smaller countries, where local book culture has been more or less dependent on foreign contacts and influences for a long time, might question if the cosmopolitan attitude has ever truly been forgotten. A new methodological turn towards transnationalism and diversity might seem less relevant when looking for examples from the Baltic Sea region, where languages, cultural and trade networks, social systems, and even states have continuously changed. In the end, contemporary book history researchers do not only have to answer whether they want to follow new methodological suggestions but also what they want to seek when examining history. The presentation discusses three topics related to the recent methodological trend that seeks to move beyond nation-states as the main object or framework of book history studies. First, the juxtaposition between national and international approaches is examined. Additionally, other concepts like "local," "regional," "domestic," "transnational," and "multinational" are conceptualized and compared to each other. Secondly, researchers should seek alternative defining frameworks: studies focusing on linguistic, social, or gender borders, rather than a national approach, would offer further insights. Finally, specific methodologies have been created for international history studies; comparative studies, studies on cultural transfer, and entangled histories all reveal different aspects of examined societies and individuals. They all belong to historians' working tools. https://www.journals.vu.lt/knygotyra/article/view/36284-
spellingShingle Jyrki Hakapää
Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
Knygotyra
-
title Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
title_full Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
title_fullStr Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
title_full_unstemmed Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
title_short Book history's recent methodological trend: national and intemational outlines
title_sort book history s recent methodological trend national and intemational outlines
topic -
url https://www.journals.vu.lt/knygotyra/article/view/36284
work_keys_str_mv AT jyrkihakapaa bookhistorysrecentmethodologicaltrendnationalandintemationaloutlines