Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers
Abstract Dental sealants, an evidence-based clinical practice, can arrest occlusal non-cavitated carious lesions (NCCLs); however, U.S. oral health providers rarely provide this treatment. To increase providers’ adoption of the practice, clinic leaders need to identify implementation strategies to d...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Nature Portfolio
2025-05-01
|
| Series: | Scientific Reports |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-03236-9 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850268739650453504 |
|---|---|
| author | Deborah E. Polk Nilesh H. Shah Tim Dawson Inga Gruß Daniel J. Pihlstrom Charles D. Kaplan Erick G. Guerrero Jeffrey L. Fellows |
| author_facet | Deborah E. Polk Nilesh H. Shah Tim Dawson Inga Gruß Daniel J. Pihlstrom Charles D. Kaplan Erick G. Guerrero Jeffrey L. Fellows |
| author_sort | Deborah E. Polk |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Dental sealants, an evidence-based clinical practice, can arrest occlusal non-cavitated carious lesions (NCCLs); however, U.S. oral health providers rarely provide this treatment. To increase providers’ adoption of the practice, clinic leaders need to identify implementation strategies to deploy. Using a stepped wedge design across 16 cluster-randomized dental clinics, we examined whether small-group deliberative engagement enabled 680 oral health providers and staff to endorse implementation strategies and to increase placement of dental sealants on occlusal NCCLs. Participants deliberated about two barriers and eight implementation strategies. Sealant placement for occlusal NCCLs was extracted from the electronic health record. After deliberating, 49% of participants endorsed the first barrier and 37% endorsed the second barrier. Of those, 26% indicated a strategy was needed for the first barrier and 28% indicated a strategy was needed for the second. Consistent with this perceived lack of need for strategies, leaders did not deploy implementation strategies. Compared with the non-intervention period (98 clinic-months), in the intervention period (101 clinic-months), providers did not increase placement of sealants on occlusal NCCLs. Deliberative engagement may help clinic leaders efficiently evaluate support for implementation strategies, but future research is needed to determine how to increase guideline adoption. Trial Registration: This project is registered at ClinicalTrials.gov with ID NCT04682730. The trial was first registered on 18/12/2020. https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04682730. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-56f6d7de19f944ffbb4051aa4aa39bfb |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 2045-2322 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-05-01 |
| publisher | Nature Portfolio |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Scientific Reports |
| spelling | doaj-art-56f6d7de19f944ffbb4051aa4aa39bfb2025-08-20T01:53:22ZengNature PortfolioScientific Reports2045-23222025-05-0115111410.1038/s41598-025-03236-9Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providersDeborah E. Polk0Nilesh H. Shah1Tim Dawson2Inga Gruß3Daniel J. Pihlstrom4Charles D. Kaplan5Erick G. Guerrero6Jeffrey L. Fellows7University of Pittsburgh School of Dental MedicineUniversity of Pittsburgh School of Dental MedicineThe Art of DemocracyKaiser Permanente Center for Health ResearchPermanente Dental AssociatesSunrise Community Counseling CenterResearch to End Healthcare Disparities CorpKaiser Permanente Center for Health ResearchAbstract Dental sealants, an evidence-based clinical practice, can arrest occlusal non-cavitated carious lesions (NCCLs); however, U.S. oral health providers rarely provide this treatment. To increase providers’ adoption of the practice, clinic leaders need to identify implementation strategies to deploy. Using a stepped wedge design across 16 cluster-randomized dental clinics, we examined whether small-group deliberative engagement enabled 680 oral health providers and staff to endorse implementation strategies and to increase placement of dental sealants on occlusal NCCLs. Participants deliberated about two barriers and eight implementation strategies. Sealant placement for occlusal NCCLs was extracted from the electronic health record. After deliberating, 49% of participants endorsed the first barrier and 37% endorsed the second barrier. Of those, 26% indicated a strategy was needed for the first barrier and 28% indicated a strategy was needed for the second. Consistent with this perceived lack of need for strategies, leaders did not deploy implementation strategies. Compared with the non-intervention period (98 clinic-months), in the intervention period (101 clinic-months), providers did not increase placement of sealants on occlusal NCCLs. Deliberative engagement may help clinic leaders efficiently evaluate support for implementation strategies, but future research is needed to determine how to increase guideline adoption. Trial Registration: This project is registered at ClinicalTrials.gov with ID NCT04682730. The trial was first registered on 18/12/2020. https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04682730.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-03236-9Implementation strategyOral healthPit and fissure sealantsDeliberative democracyGuideline adherenceProvider autonomy |
| spellingShingle | Deborah E. Polk Nilesh H. Shah Tim Dawson Inga Gruß Daniel J. Pihlstrom Charles D. Kaplan Erick G. Guerrero Jeffrey L. Fellows Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers Scientific Reports Implementation strategy Oral health Pit and fissure sealants Deliberative democracy Guideline adherence Provider autonomy |
| title | Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers |
| title_full | Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers |
| title_fullStr | Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers |
| title_full_unstemmed | Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers |
| title_short | Results from a cluster-randomized, stepped-wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among U.S. oral health providers |
| title_sort | results from a cluster randomized stepped wedge trial testing a deliberative engagement intervention to increase guideline adherence among u s oral health providers |
| topic | Implementation strategy Oral health Pit and fissure sealants Deliberative democracy Guideline adherence Provider autonomy |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-03236-9 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT deborahepolk resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT nileshhshah resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT timdawson resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT ingagruß resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT danieljpihlstrom resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT charlesdkaplan resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT erickgguerrero resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders AT jeffreylfellows resultsfromaclusterrandomizedsteppedwedgetrialtestingadeliberativeengagementinterventiontoincreaseguidelineadherenceamongusoralhealthproviders |