A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography
Abstract Stemflow is a key process in forested catchments due to its control on soil water content and nutrients’ transport. However, there are still few studies focusing on stemflow infiltration and relying on direct observations that are minimally invasive and repeatable. In this study, we exploit...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Wiley
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Vadose Zone Journal |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1002/vzj2.20397 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850229150899503104 |
|---|---|
| author | G. Zuecco C. Marchina M. Censini D. Todini‐Zicavo G. Cassiani M. Borga |
| author_facet | G. Zuecco C. Marchina M. Censini D. Todini‐Zicavo G. Cassiani M. Borga |
| author_sort | G. Zuecco |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Stemflow is a key process in forested catchments due to its control on soil water content and nutrients’ transport. However, there are still few studies focusing on stemflow infiltration and relying on direct observations that are minimally invasive and repeatable. In this study, we exploited the usefulness of stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen, as well as of time‐lapse electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) to investigate water fluxes in the soil. Specifically, we aimed to examine the effectiveness of both isotopes and ERT to trace stemflow infiltration for a beech tree in a steep hillslope in the Italian pre‐Alps, to quantify stemflow infiltration area based on the two methodologies and to provide recommendations for future research. Results showed that both approaches identified an infiltration along the maximum slope gradient with most of the water staying in the upper 45 cm of soil. The analysis of electrical resistivity variations enabled to evaluate the temporal dynamics of stemflow infiltration and to estimate an average stemflow infiltration area of 0.64 m2, which was larger than values found by previous studies based on dye tracers. This high estimate may be due to multiple factors, from the soil conditions to methodological uncertainties. Conversely, the estimation of stemflow infiltration area based on isotopes was affected by the sampling area. Hence, future research based on isotopic tracers needs to consider methods providing a direct field evidence of stemflow infiltration (e.g., dye tracers) or a quick inspection of raw data (e.g., ERT) to inform the sampling design. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-46ee1316859944e1bbb06a6ddfc627e2 |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 1539-1663 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Vadose Zone Journal |
| spelling | doaj-art-46ee1316859944e1bbb06a6ddfc627e22025-08-20T02:04:19ZengWileyVadose Zone Journal1539-16632025-01-01241n/an/a10.1002/vzj2.20397A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomographyG. Zuecco0C. Marchina1M. Censini2D. Todini‐Zicavo3G. Cassiani4M. Borga5Department of Land, Environment, Agriculture and ForestryUniversity of PadovaLegnaro ItalyDepartment of Land, Environment, Agriculture and ForestryUniversity of PadovaLegnaro ItalyDepartment of GeosciencesUniversity of PadovaPadovaItalyDepartment of Land, Environment, Agriculture and ForestryUniversity of PadovaLegnaro ItalyDepartment of GeosciencesUniversity of PadovaPadovaItalyDepartment of Land, Environment, Agriculture and ForestryUniversity of PadovaLegnaro ItalyAbstract Stemflow is a key process in forested catchments due to its control on soil water content and nutrients’ transport. However, there are still few studies focusing on stemflow infiltration and relying on direct observations that are minimally invasive and repeatable. In this study, we exploited the usefulness of stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen, as well as of time‐lapse electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) to investigate water fluxes in the soil. Specifically, we aimed to examine the effectiveness of both isotopes and ERT to trace stemflow infiltration for a beech tree in a steep hillslope in the Italian pre‐Alps, to quantify stemflow infiltration area based on the two methodologies and to provide recommendations for future research. Results showed that both approaches identified an infiltration along the maximum slope gradient with most of the water staying in the upper 45 cm of soil. The analysis of electrical resistivity variations enabled to evaluate the temporal dynamics of stemflow infiltration and to estimate an average stemflow infiltration area of 0.64 m2, which was larger than values found by previous studies based on dye tracers. This high estimate may be due to multiple factors, from the soil conditions to methodological uncertainties. Conversely, the estimation of stemflow infiltration area based on isotopes was affected by the sampling area. Hence, future research based on isotopic tracers needs to consider methods providing a direct field evidence of stemflow infiltration (e.g., dye tracers) or a quick inspection of raw data (e.g., ERT) to inform the sampling design.https://doi.org/10.1002/vzj2.20397 |
| spellingShingle | G. Zuecco C. Marchina M. Censini D. Todini‐Zicavo G. Cassiani M. Borga A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography Vadose Zone Journal |
| title | A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| title_full | A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| title_fullStr | A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| title_full_unstemmed | A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| title_short | A simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration: Advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| title_sort | simple experiment to trace stemflow infiltration advantages and challenges of using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen and electrical resistivity tomography |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1002/vzj2.20397 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT gzuecco asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT cmarchina asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT mcensini asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT dtodinizicavo asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT gcassiani asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT mborga asimpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT gzuecco simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT cmarchina simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT mcensini simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT dtodinizicavo simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT gcassiani simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography AT mborga simpleexperimenttotracestemflowinfiltrationadvantagesandchallengesofusingstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygenandelectricalresistivitytomography |