How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)

Previous research has shown that Western news media often portray Islam and Muslims in a negative light. However, negativity is an inherent feature of media logic. Defining Islam and Muslims as the problem e.g. the “bad news”, in turn, is neither inherent to media logic nor a natural consequence of...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Liriam Sponholz, Anna-Maria Meuth
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Elsevier 2025-01-01
Series:Social Sciences and Humanities Open
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259029112500018X
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1832583839224954880
author Liriam Sponholz
Anna-Maria Meuth
author_facet Liriam Sponholz
Anna-Maria Meuth
author_sort Liriam Sponholz
collection DOAJ
description Previous research has shown that Western news media often portray Islam and Muslims in a negative light. However, negativity is an inherent feature of media logic. Defining Islam and Muslims as the problem e.g. the “bad news”, in turn, is neither inherent to media logic nor a natural consequence of events. This study attempts to shift the focus from the valence of media representations to the interplay between media attention and problem definition by analysing whether and how events trigger media attention on Muslims and change the media agenda. To answer this question, an automated quantitative content analysis was conducted on all articles of at least 50 words mentioning Islam∗ or Muslims∗ in broadsheets from the UK, Germany and France published between 2000 and 2020 (N = 262,105). This database permitted a time series analysis to determine a) when the issues of Islam and Muslims received (no) attention and b) what events led to the “ups” or peaks in attention. Following that, a co-occurrence network analysis of the term “Muslim” based on the media data before and after a trigger event identified c) how “ups” and “downs” shape media agenda on Islam. The results show that media attention on Islam and Muslims is highly unevenly distributed and concentrated in the aftermath of single terrorist attacks, rather than on religiously motivated terrorist attacks in general. Furthermore, these triggering terrorist attacks lead to a convergence of the media agenda and an essentialisation of Islam and Muslims.
format Article
id doaj-art-36b9f6a706b94fd58414efd7e3ac4165
institution Kabale University
issn 2590-2911
language English
publishDate 2025-01-01
publisher Elsevier
record_format Article
series Social Sciences and Humanities Open
spelling doaj-art-36b9f6a706b94fd58414efd7e3ac41652025-01-28T04:14:53ZengElsevierSocial Sciences and Humanities Open2590-29112025-01-0111101291How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)Liriam Sponholz0Anna-Maria Meuth1University of Brasilia and German Centre for Integration and Migration Research (DeZIM Institute), Mauerstraße 76, 10117, Berlin, Germany; Corresponding author.German Centre for Integration and Migration Research (DeZIM Institute), Mauerstraße 76, 10117, Berlin, GermanyPrevious research has shown that Western news media often portray Islam and Muslims in a negative light. However, negativity is an inherent feature of media logic. Defining Islam and Muslims as the problem e.g. the “bad news”, in turn, is neither inherent to media logic nor a natural consequence of events. This study attempts to shift the focus from the valence of media representations to the interplay between media attention and problem definition by analysing whether and how events trigger media attention on Muslims and change the media agenda. To answer this question, an automated quantitative content analysis was conducted on all articles of at least 50 words mentioning Islam∗ or Muslims∗ in broadsheets from the UK, Germany and France published between 2000 and 2020 (N = 262,105). This database permitted a time series analysis to determine a) when the issues of Islam and Muslims received (no) attention and b) what events led to the “ups” or peaks in attention. Following that, a co-occurrence network analysis of the term “Muslim” based on the media data before and after a trigger event identified c) how “ups” and “downs” shape media agenda on Islam. The results show that media attention on Islam and Muslims is highly unevenly distributed and concentrated in the aftermath of single terrorist attacks, rather than on religiously motivated terrorist attacks in general. Furthermore, these triggering terrorist attacks lead to a convergence of the media agenda and an essentialisation of Islam and Muslims.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259029112500018XIslamMedia stormsMedia agendaGermanyFranceUK
spellingShingle Liriam Sponholz
Anna-Maria Meuth
How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
Social Sciences and Humanities Open
Islam
Media storms
Media agenda
Germany
France
UK
title How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
title_full How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
title_fullStr How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
title_full_unstemmed How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
title_short How do events shape the media agenda on Islam and Muslims in Western Europe? An analysis of news events in Germany, the UK and France (2000–2020)
title_sort how do events shape the media agenda on islam and muslims in western europe an analysis of news events in germany the uk and france 2000 2020
topic Islam
Media storms
Media agenda
Germany
France
UK
url http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259029112500018X
work_keys_str_mv AT liriamsponholz howdoeventsshapethemediaagendaonislamandmuslimsinwesterneuropeananalysisofnewseventsingermanytheukandfrance20002020
AT annamariameuth howdoeventsshapethemediaagendaonislamandmuslimsinwesterneuropeananalysisofnewseventsingermanytheukandfrance20002020