The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques
Abstract Purpose Post‐operative meniscal cyst formation occurs following all‐inside device meniscal repair. This study aimed to compare the incidence of cysts in patients who underwent meniscal repair with and without all‐inside suture devices. Methods This retrospective study included 227 knees tha...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Wiley
2024-10-01
|
| Series: | Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70049 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850033066637000704 |
|---|---|
| author | Kazumi Goto Takaki Sanada Eisaburo Honda Shin Sameshima Miyu Inagawa Yutaro Ishida Koji Matsuo Ryota Kuzuhara Hiroshi Iwaso |
| author_facet | Kazumi Goto Takaki Sanada Eisaburo Honda Shin Sameshima Miyu Inagawa Yutaro Ishida Koji Matsuo Ryota Kuzuhara Hiroshi Iwaso |
| author_sort | Kazumi Goto |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Purpose Post‐operative meniscal cyst formation occurs following all‐inside device meniscal repair. This study aimed to compare the incidence of cysts in patients who underwent meniscal repair with and without all‐inside suture devices. Methods This retrospective study included 227 knees that underwent meniscal repair between 2021 and 2022. The incidence of post‐operative meniscal cysts was compared between patients who underwent repair using an all‐inside suture anchor device (Group SA) and those who did not use an anchor (Group NA), based on post‐operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings. Risk factors, such as the number of anchors used, were investigated. Using a subgroup analysis, the incidence of meniscal cysts based on the type of device used was investigated. Results Groups SA and NA comprised 125 and 102 knees, respectively. Group SA had 11 cases of cysts (9% incidence), whereas Group NA had 7 cases (7% incidence), and no statistically significant difference was observed (p = 0.63). Symptomatic cysts were observed in two patients (1.6%) in Group SA, whereas none was observed in Group NA (0%); the difference was not significant (p = 0.50). Factors such as the number of anchors and sutures used and MRI timing were not identified as risk factors. Cyst incidence varied according to anchor type: Stryker AIR+ (4 out of 55, 7%), Smith & Nephew Fast‐Fix 360 (7 out of 56, 13%) and Arthrex Fiber Stitch (0 out of 26, 0%), with no significant difference found (p = 0.14). Conclusion The incidence of cysts in patients undergoing meniscal repair with an all‐inside suture anchor device was 9%, showing no significant difference compared with Group NA. Cyst incidence was not affected by device type. Level of Evidence Level III, retrospective comparative study. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-2f00f9d022964ae0ac43a040c9fa6ff8 |
| institution | DOAJ |
| issn | 2197-1153 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2024-10-01 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics |
| spelling | doaj-art-2f00f9d022964ae0ac43a040c9fa6ff82025-08-20T02:58:21ZengWileyJournal of Experimental Orthopaedics2197-11532024-10-01114n/an/a10.1002/jeo2.70049The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniquesKazumi Goto0Takaki Sanada1Eisaburo Honda2Shin Sameshima3Miyu Inagawa4Yutaro Ishida5Koji Matsuo6Ryota Kuzuhara7Hiroshi Iwaso8Department of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanDepartment of Sports Orthopedic Surgery Kanto Rosai Hospital Kanagawa JapanAbstract Purpose Post‐operative meniscal cyst formation occurs following all‐inside device meniscal repair. This study aimed to compare the incidence of cysts in patients who underwent meniscal repair with and without all‐inside suture devices. Methods This retrospective study included 227 knees that underwent meniscal repair between 2021 and 2022. The incidence of post‐operative meniscal cysts was compared between patients who underwent repair using an all‐inside suture anchor device (Group SA) and those who did not use an anchor (Group NA), based on post‐operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings. Risk factors, such as the number of anchors used, were investigated. Using a subgroup analysis, the incidence of meniscal cysts based on the type of device used was investigated. Results Groups SA and NA comprised 125 and 102 knees, respectively. Group SA had 11 cases of cysts (9% incidence), whereas Group NA had 7 cases (7% incidence), and no statistically significant difference was observed (p = 0.63). Symptomatic cysts were observed in two patients (1.6%) in Group SA, whereas none was observed in Group NA (0%); the difference was not significant (p = 0.50). Factors such as the number of anchors and sutures used and MRI timing were not identified as risk factors. Cyst incidence varied according to anchor type: Stryker AIR+ (4 out of 55, 7%), Smith & Nephew Fast‐Fix 360 (7 out of 56, 13%) and Arthrex Fiber Stitch (0 out of 26, 0%), with no significant difference found (p = 0.14). Conclusion The incidence of cysts in patients undergoing meniscal repair with an all‐inside suture anchor device was 9%, showing no significant difference compared with Group NA. Cyst incidence was not affected by device type. Level of Evidence Level III, retrospective comparative study.https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70049all‐inside sutureanchor devicekneemeniscal cystmeniscal repair |
| spellingShingle | Kazumi Goto Takaki Sanada Eisaburo Honda Shin Sameshima Miyu Inagawa Yutaro Ishida Koji Matsuo Ryota Kuzuhara Hiroshi Iwaso The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics all‐inside suture anchor device knee meniscal cyst meniscal repair |
| title | The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| title_full | The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| title_fullStr | The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| title_full_unstemmed | The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| title_short | The incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all‐inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| title_sort | incidence of meniscal cyst formation following meniscal repair using the all inside suture anchor device is comparable to conventional techniques |
| topic | all‐inside suture anchor device knee meniscal cyst meniscal repair |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1002/jeo2.70049 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT kazumigoto theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT takakisanada theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT eisaburohonda theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT shinsameshima theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT miyuinagawa theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT yutaroishida theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT kojimatsuo theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT ryotakuzuhara theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT hiroshiiwaso theincidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT kazumigoto incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT takakisanada incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT eisaburohonda incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT shinsameshima incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT miyuinagawa incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT yutaroishida incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT kojimatsuo incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT ryotakuzuhara incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques AT hiroshiiwaso incidenceofmeniscalcystformationfollowingmeniscalrepairusingtheallinsidesutureanchordeviceiscomparabletoconventionaltechniques |