Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art
Winner of the Fabian Dorsch ESA Essay Prize. David Davies advocates a methodological principle he calls the ‘pragmatic constraint’, according to which ontology of art is answerable to epistemology of art, or ‘those features of our creative, critical, appreciative, and individuative practices in the...
Saved in:
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Helsinki University Press
2025-03-01
|
| Series: | Estetika |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://account.estetikajournal.org/index.php/uh-j-eteja/article/view/545 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1850197265519476736 |
|---|---|
| author | David Collins |
| author_facet | David Collins |
| author_sort | David Collins |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Winner of the Fabian Dorsch ESA Essay Prize. David Davies advocates a methodological principle he calls the ‘pragmatic constraint’, according to which ontology of art is answerable to epistemology of art, or ‘those features of our creative, critical, appreciative, and individuative practices in the arts that would withstand rational scrutiny’. This principle, while widely endorsed, has faced scepticism, charges of vagueness, and ambiguity concerning what counts as an instance of its correct application. I propose a similar principle that avoids these problems while doing the work for which the pragmatic constraint is meant, and one that is expanded in scope to apply to philosophy of art generally. Drawing on ideas from classical pragmatism, this new ‘pragmatist principle’ holds that (1) philosophy of art should centrally deal with philosophical problems that could arise for a reflective practitioner in the course of artistic practice, and (2) the solutions offered to those problems should be able to make some positive difference for, or tie back into and inform, future artistic practice, with ‘practice’ here including both art’s creation and its reception. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-2ea123a3b9a14d7cbc33286c6a7f9ddb |
| institution | OA Journals |
| issn | 2571-0915 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-03-01 |
| publisher | Helsinki University Press |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Estetika |
| spelling | doaj-art-2ea123a3b9a14d7cbc33286c6a7f9ddb2025-08-20T02:13:13ZengHelsinki University PressEstetika2571-09152025-03-016211–161–1610.33134/eeja.545522Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about ArtDavid Collins0Churchill College, CambridgeWinner of the Fabian Dorsch ESA Essay Prize. David Davies advocates a methodological principle he calls the ‘pragmatic constraint’, according to which ontology of art is answerable to epistemology of art, or ‘those features of our creative, critical, appreciative, and individuative practices in the arts that would withstand rational scrutiny’. This principle, while widely endorsed, has faced scepticism, charges of vagueness, and ambiguity concerning what counts as an instance of its correct application. I propose a similar principle that avoids these problems while doing the work for which the pragmatic constraint is meant, and one that is expanded in scope to apply to philosophy of art generally. Drawing on ideas from classical pragmatism, this new ‘pragmatist principle’ holds that (1) philosophy of art should centrally deal with philosophical problems that could arise for a reflective practitioner in the course of artistic practice, and (2) the solutions offered to those problems should be able to make some positive difference for, or tie back into and inform, future artistic practice, with ‘practice’ here including both art’s creation and its reception.https://account.estetikajournal.org/index.php/uh-j-eteja/article/view/545metaphilosophy of artpragmatic constraintpragmatismjohn deweywilliam jamesartistic practice |
| spellingShingle | David Collins Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art Estetika metaphilosophy of art pragmatic constraint pragmatism john dewey william james artistic practice |
| title | Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art |
| title_full | Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art |
| title_fullStr | Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art |
| title_full_unstemmed | Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art |
| title_short | Expanding Davies’s Pragmatic Constraint: A Pragmatist Principle for Philosophizing about Art |
| title_sort | expanding davies s pragmatic constraint a pragmatist principle for philosophizing about art |
| topic | metaphilosophy of art pragmatic constraint pragmatism john dewey william james artistic practice |
| url | https://account.estetikajournal.org/index.php/uh-j-eteja/article/view/545 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT davidcollins expandingdaviesspragmaticconstraintapragmatistprincipleforphilosophizingaboutart |