A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students
Background Evidence suggests that targeted interventions can improve medical students’ perceptions of professionalism and professional identity formation, resilience and coping skills. However, it is unclear how many educational sessions are required for a meaningful impact. We aimed to determine th...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Taylor & Francis Group
2025-12-01
|
| Series: | Medical Education Online |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/10872981.2025.2529964 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1849714621831708672 |
|---|---|
| author | David Byrne Anne Hickey Denis Harkin Aine Ryan Catherine Moran Fiona Boland Jan Illing Lorna Staines Mohamed Abdelnasser Lisa Mellon Caroline Kelleher Frank Doyle |
| author_facet | David Byrne Anne Hickey Denis Harkin Aine Ryan Catherine Moran Fiona Boland Jan Illing Lorna Staines Mohamed Abdelnasser Lisa Mellon Caroline Kelleher Frank Doyle |
| author_sort | David Byrne |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Background Evidence suggests that targeted interventions can improve medical students’ perceptions of professionalism and professional identity formation, resilience and coping skills. However, it is unclear how many educational sessions are required for a meaningful impact. We aimed to determine the impact of single resilience/professionalism tutorials on Year 1 medical students’ coping self-efficacy and resilience and perceptions of professionalism and professional identity formation. We also conducted a qualitative process evaluation.Methods A cluster crossover design was used to evaluate tutorials. Student groups were randomly allocated to ‘resilience first’ and ‘professionalism first’ classes, followed immediately by the alternative tutorial. Students (n = 106) completed the Coping Self-Efficacy Scale (CSES) and Penn State Questionnaire on Professionalism (PSCOM) before the first tutorial, between tutorials, and after the second tutorial. Differences in CSES and PSCOM scores between groups were assessed using multivariate analysis of variance. Findings were presented to students (n=6) and focus group data were analysed using reflective thematic analysis.Results Within-group effects showed significant increases in scores for CSES and PSCOM, but irrespective of original group allocation. Qualitative results suggested three themes: positive aspects, limitations, and improving training. Several logistical issues were identified that may have inhibited tutorial efficacy.Conclusion While we found increased self-efficacy and professionalism scores, these could not be related to the efficacy of respective single tutorials, suggesting that multiple tutorials are required to impact these outcomes. While cross-over designs are feasible to implement, logistical issues may detract from their efficacy. Tutorials could potentially be improved by introducing more interactive learning methods. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-163bdf2bd0034bf8a98283964a92d37f |
| institution | DOAJ |
| issn | 1087-2981 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-12-01 |
| publisher | Taylor & Francis Group |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Medical Education Online |
| spelling | doaj-art-163bdf2bd0034bf8a98283964a92d37f2025-08-20T03:13:39ZengTaylor & Francis GroupMedical Education Online1087-29812025-12-0130110.1080/10872981.2025.2529964A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical studentsDavid Byrne0Anne Hickey1Denis Harkin2Aine Ryan3Catherine Moran4Fiona Boland5Jan Illing6Lorna Staines7Mohamed Abdelnasser8Lisa Mellon9Caroline Kelleher10Frank Doyle11Department of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandCentre for Professionalism in Medicine and Health Sciences, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandCentre for Professionalism in Medicine and Health Sciences, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandData Science Centre, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandHealth Professions Education Centre, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandDepartment of Health Psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, IrelandBackground Evidence suggests that targeted interventions can improve medical students’ perceptions of professionalism and professional identity formation, resilience and coping skills. However, it is unclear how many educational sessions are required for a meaningful impact. We aimed to determine the impact of single resilience/professionalism tutorials on Year 1 medical students’ coping self-efficacy and resilience and perceptions of professionalism and professional identity formation. We also conducted a qualitative process evaluation.Methods A cluster crossover design was used to evaluate tutorials. Student groups were randomly allocated to ‘resilience first’ and ‘professionalism first’ classes, followed immediately by the alternative tutorial. Students (n = 106) completed the Coping Self-Efficacy Scale (CSES) and Penn State Questionnaire on Professionalism (PSCOM) before the first tutorial, between tutorials, and after the second tutorial. Differences in CSES and PSCOM scores between groups were assessed using multivariate analysis of variance. Findings were presented to students (n=6) and focus group data were analysed using reflective thematic analysis.Results Within-group effects showed significant increases in scores for CSES and PSCOM, but irrespective of original group allocation. Qualitative results suggested three themes: positive aspects, limitations, and improving training. Several logistical issues were identified that may have inhibited tutorial efficacy.Conclusion While we found increased self-efficacy and professionalism scores, these could not be related to the efficacy of respective single tutorials, suggesting that multiple tutorials are required to impact these outcomes. While cross-over designs are feasible to implement, logistical issues may detract from their efficacy. Tutorials could potentially be improved by introducing more interactive learning methods.https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/10872981.2025.2529964Medical education researchprofessional identityprofessionalismresilienceself-efficacy |
| spellingShingle | David Byrne Anne Hickey Denis Harkin Aine Ryan Catherine Moran Fiona Boland Jan Illing Lorna Staines Mohamed Abdelnasser Lisa Mellon Caroline Kelleher Frank Doyle A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students Medical Education Online Medical education research professional identity professionalism resilience self-efficacy |
| title | A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| title_full | A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| title_fullStr | A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| title_full_unstemmed | A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| title_short | A cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| title_sort | cluster randomised crossover trial of single resilience and professionalism tutorials among undergraduate medical students |
| topic | Medical education research professional identity professionalism resilience self-efficacy |
| url | https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/10872981.2025.2529964 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT davidbyrne aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT annehickey aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT denisharkin aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT aineryan aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT catherinemoran aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT fionaboland aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT janilling aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT lornastaines aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT mohamedabdelnasser aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT lisamellon aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT carolinekelleher aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT frankdoyle aclusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT davidbyrne clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT annehickey clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT denisharkin clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT aineryan clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT catherinemoran clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT fionaboland clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT janilling clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT lornastaines clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT mohamedabdelnasser clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT lisamellon clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT carolinekelleher clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents AT frankdoyle clusterrandomisedcrossovertrialofsingleresilienceandprofessionalismtutorialsamongundergraduatemedicalstudents |