Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers
# Background Clinicians of many specialties within sports medicine care for athletes with shoulder instability, but successful outcomes are inconsistent. Consistency across specialties in the diagnosis of shoulder instability is critical for care of the athlete, yet the extent of divergence in its d...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
North American Sports Medicine Institute
2021-08-01
|
| Series: | International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.26603/001c.25170 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1825196984067162112 |
|---|---|
| author | Constantine P Nicolozakes Xinning Li Tim L Uhl Guido Marra Nitin B Jain Eric J Perreault Amee L Seitz |
| author_facet | Constantine P Nicolozakes Xinning Li Tim L Uhl Guido Marra Nitin B Jain Eric J Perreault Amee L Seitz |
| author_sort | Constantine P Nicolozakes |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | # Background
Clinicians of many specialties within sports medicine care for athletes with shoulder instability, but successful outcomes are inconsistent. Consistency across specialties in the diagnosis of shoulder instability is critical for care of the athlete, yet the extent of divergence in its diagnosis is unknown.
# Hypothesis
Physicians differ from rehabilitation providers in which findings they deem clinically important to differentiate shoulder instability from impingement, and in how they diagnose athlete scenarios with atraumatic shoulder instability.
# Study Design
Cross-sectional study.
# Methods
Physicians (orthopaedic surgeons, primary care sports medicine physicians) and rehabilitation providers (physical therapists, athletic trainers) were asked via an online survey to rate clinical factors used to diagnose shoulder instability. Clinicians were also asked to diagnose two athlete scenarios with concurrent clinical findings of atraumatic shoulder instability and impingement, differentiated by the absence or presence of a positive sulcus sign.
# Results
Responses were recorded from 888 clinicians. Orthopaedic surgeons (N=170) and primary care sports medicine physicians (N=108) ranked physical examination factors as more important for the diagnosis of shoulder instability than patient history factors, whereas physical therapists (N=379) and athletic trainers (N=231) preferred patient history factors. Orthopaedic surgeons differed from physical therapists and athletic trainers in their clinical diagnoses for both scenarios (*P*≤0.001).
# Conclusion
A lack of consistency exists among sports medicine clinicians in recognizing which clinical factors are important when used to diagnose shoulder instability and in diagnoses given with concurrent findings of impingement.
# Level of Evidence
Level 3. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-03ca82e1d29a444ca30e758592399334 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2159-2896 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2021-08-01 |
| publisher | North American Sports Medicine Institute |
| record_format | Article |
| series | International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy |
| spelling | doaj-art-03ca82e1d29a444ca30e7585923993342025-02-11T20:27:50ZengNorth American Sports Medicine InstituteInternational Journal of Sports Physical Therapy2159-28962021-08-01164Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation ProvidersConstantine P NicolozakesXinning LiTim L UhlGuido MarraNitin B JainEric J PerreaultAmee L Seitz# Background Clinicians of many specialties within sports medicine care for athletes with shoulder instability, but successful outcomes are inconsistent. Consistency across specialties in the diagnosis of shoulder instability is critical for care of the athlete, yet the extent of divergence in its diagnosis is unknown. # Hypothesis Physicians differ from rehabilitation providers in which findings they deem clinically important to differentiate shoulder instability from impingement, and in how they diagnose athlete scenarios with atraumatic shoulder instability. # Study Design Cross-sectional study. # Methods Physicians (orthopaedic surgeons, primary care sports medicine physicians) and rehabilitation providers (physical therapists, athletic trainers) were asked via an online survey to rate clinical factors used to diagnose shoulder instability. Clinicians were also asked to diagnose two athlete scenarios with concurrent clinical findings of atraumatic shoulder instability and impingement, differentiated by the absence or presence of a positive sulcus sign. # Results Responses were recorded from 888 clinicians. Orthopaedic surgeons (N=170) and primary care sports medicine physicians (N=108) ranked physical examination factors as more important for the diagnosis of shoulder instability than patient history factors, whereas physical therapists (N=379) and athletic trainers (N=231) preferred patient history factors. Orthopaedic surgeons differed from physical therapists and athletic trainers in their clinical diagnoses for both scenarios (*P*≤0.001). # Conclusion A lack of consistency exists among sports medicine clinicians in recognizing which clinical factors are important when used to diagnose shoulder instability and in diagnoses given with concurrent findings of impingement. # Level of Evidence Level 3.https://doi.org/10.26603/001c.25170 |
| spellingShingle | Constantine P Nicolozakes Xinning Li Tim L Uhl Guido Marra Nitin B Jain Eric J Perreault Amee L Seitz Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy |
| title | Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers |
| title_full | Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers |
| title_fullStr | Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers |
| title_full_unstemmed | Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers |
| title_short | Interprofessional Inconsistencies in the Diagnosis of Shoulder Instability: Survey Results of Physicians and Rehabilitation Providers |
| title_sort | interprofessional inconsistencies in the diagnosis of shoulder instability survey results of physicians and rehabilitation providers |
| url | https://doi.org/10.26603/001c.25170 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT constantinepnicolozakes interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT xinningli interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT timluhl interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT guidomarra interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT nitinbjain interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT ericjperreault interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders AT ameelseitz interprofessionalinconsistenciesinthediagnosisofshoulderinstabilitysurveyresultsofphysiciansandrehabilitationproviders |